Dr Boyce Money: What is the Financial Cost of Racism?

Comments (2)

I recently did an interview with Charlamagne Tha God (posted below) with 100.3 "The Beat" in Philadelphia. Charlamagne keeps me up with the most interesting news in Philly, usually shocking me every single week. You'd be amazed at how many astonishing stories never make the national media. The latest story was an interesting case in which a group of children from a predominantly black and latino daycare were kicked out of the swimming pool at a country club that is predominantly white.

The children overheard the parents at the pool making racially charged statements, and they also were not given an explanation from the owners of the club as to why they were being excluded. The daycare was given their money back, and told not to return.

This case brought up some interesting thoughts about whether or not racism pays the bills.

Forgive me for being irritatingly objective in my analysis, but I want to put aside the fact that I am a black man for just a second. Don't get me wrong, if my children were being unfairly put out of a swimming pool, I might be out breaking legs. I refuse to allow those I love to be treated as second-class citizens.

But there is another issue to be considered here: whether or not it makes economic sense for the owners of this pool to kick these kids out. Even if the owners were not racist themselves (which I will - perhaps incorrectly - assume they were not), we have to realize that doing the right thing doesn't always pay the bills. Slavery lasted for hundreds of years, not because people thought it was a good thing, but because the entire cotton industry was dependent upon slave labor. The same is true for the NCAA, where everyone logically sees that the athletes' families should be compensated, but such compensation would hurt the bottom line of those who are getting rich off black families.

In the case of the country club, the owners may have removed the children from the pool because their existing clientele were not in favor of having these children in the pool with them. It could have been because the new kids were black, because they were poor, or because they were not members. Either way, they were excluded and many are perceiving this to be an act of racism.

The challenge for the owners of the club, however, is that the financial benefit of keeping your current members happy comes at a tremendous price. First, there is the fact that the daycare may actually sue you. I stated clearly in the interview with Charlamagne that they should see if they have a legal case against the country club. If someone is going to be ignorant, it is only natural that they be required to pay the "ignorance tax," which comes from a lawsuit settlement.

Secondly, there is the negative publicity. Whether the director of this country club sees himself as being racist, the truth is that it doesn't matter much to the public right now. They are going to be known across America as the pool that wouldn't let the black kids swim. Perhaps you could get away with such an image in 1945, but you can't get away with it now. Even Sean Hannity won't stand by that one.

Slave History Unearthed

    Actress Diane Johnson portrays "Sarah," a fictional slave during speaks to a tour group in character at Christ Church's cemetery in Philadelphia. Philadelphia's most famous Colonial-era church is opening the eyes of visitors with the revelation: Slaves worshiped alongside parishioners like Washington, Benjamin Franklin and Betsy Ross.

    AP

    The remains of buildings, including the house George Washington lived in while he was president, are shown at the sight of an archaeological dig in front of the Liberty Bell Center, top right, in Philadelphia, in this June 5, 2007, file photo. Historic Philadelphia's ties to slavery emerged in a big way in 2007 as an estimated 250,000 people witnessed the excavation of a slave passageway in the President's House, where Washington lived while Philadelphia was the nation's capital.

    AP

    Democratic presidential hopeful Sen. Barack Obama D-Ill., speaks about race during a news conference just blocks from Independence Hall and the Christ Church burial ground in Philadelphia, Tuesday, March 18, 2008. the city's most famous Colonial-era church is opening the eyes of visitors with a revelation: Slaves worshipped alongside parishioners like Washington, Benjamin Franklin and Betsy Ross.

    AP

    The city's ties to slavery emerged in 2007 as an estimated 250,000 people witnessed the excavation of a slave passageway in the President's House, where Washington lived while Philadelphia was the nation's capital.

    AP

    As "Sarah," Johnson plays a fictional slave who puts a human face on the grim statistics: In 1760, Philadelphia's population was 11,000; about 1,100 were black, and nearly 900 of them were slaves.

    AP

    Founded in 1695, Christ Church was the first parish of the Church of England in Pennsylvania and the birthplace of the U.S. Episcopal Church. Tours are given daily, but special presentations on Tuesday and Thursday afternoons offer slavery-related narratives.

    AP


Third, there is the obvious fact that they chose to give $1,950 dollars in swimming pool fees back to the daycare. Giving money back doesn't exactly help your bottom line.

Speaking of the bottom line, my bottom line is this: Many people chose to let go of racism in the past, not because they truly cared about black people, but because they realized that racial constraints don't usually make economic sense. Some companies choose to get rid of the glass ceiling because it is difficult to compete when you are not choosing the best person for the job. Our nation has a black president because Americans realized that it would not be economically prudent to pass up an intelligent black man for a couple of mediocre politicians. Similarly, the country club may have thrown away good money to maintain their status quo, but there is surely a more intelligent business owner out there who will accept these kids with open arms.

Hopefully, this country club will soon see that racism is not only socially distasteful, it is also economically ignorant. The interview with Charlamagne is here if you'd like to listen.

Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Finance Professor at Syracuse University and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money," set for release on July 15, 2009. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email, please click here.

Comments: (2)

Add a comment

Page 1 of 1

Add a Comment

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed but they are required to confirm your comments. When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password."

Most Commented Articles

Daily Drama

The Best Clips From TV's Hottest Shows



From Our Partners

Find a Message Board

Discover conversations on everyone from Barack to Beyonce. There are nearly 50 forums, so click on a category below and find the right one for you.