I spoke about Chris Brown on CNN not too long ago, and I am sure I'll be talking about him now. Given his shocking 5-year probationary smackdown by a judge, I am sure that Chris has been humbled beyond belief. Even I was surprised to see him get this kind of punishment. But the truth is that when we make personal decisions, there is a piper to be paid, and sometimes that piper wants more compensation than we wish to deliver.
But Chris Brown is far from finished, and I expect him to be back on top in no time. The Chris Brown brand is still worth hundreds of millions of dollars, since corporate America is very good at working around the emotional to secure the logical value of their financial assets. Here are some things to keep in mind as Chris tries to rebuild his damaged career.
If R. Kelly can make a comeback, anybody can. I confess that R. Kelly honestly sickens me. I hate to say it this way, but the idea of a man doing what he is alleged to have done to that little girl makes me as angry as you can ever possibly imagine (and yes, I do believe that was him in that video). What disturbs me even more is that the American public let the entire issue go as soon as Kelly released another hit song. This sends a horrible message to young black women, reflecting the fact that our culture does not value their well-being as much as we value a hit song about going to the club, getting drunk and having irresponsible sex at the end of the night. Sorry homeboy, but you can't serenade your way into my good graces or that of any other conscientious African American. There are simply some lines entertainers cannot cross and being found "not guilty" is not the same as being found innocent.
In spite of the obvious critique one can thrust on R. Kelly, the oddest thing is that R. Kelly's model of career recovery can serve as an instruction manual for Chris Brown. The first segment of that lesson came during R. Kelly's first BET interview after the child pornography allegations were made. During the interview, I noticed that the singer kept repeating the phrase, "Just focus on my music." He repeated the phrase several times, as if his business manager had coached him to do so. Upon processing things later, the translation here was simple: If you are focused on his music, you will forgive him for the fact that he'd been accused of doing nasty things to someone's 13-year-old daughter. Yes it's sick. Yes, it bothers me. But yes, it's the truth and it has worked quite well for R. Kelly and his business model (notice that it took him a while to release his latest album after the trial -- the public typically cools off and forgets almost anything you've done if enough time passes).
Chris Brown Photos
Singer Chris Brown leaves the Los Angeles Superior Court after sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. TOPSHOTS AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown (L) listens with his lawyer Mark Geragos (R) inside the Los Angeles Superior Court during the sentencing in his felony assault case against Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/POOL/Rick LOOMIS (Photo credit should read RICK LOOMIS/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown reacts inside the Los Angeles Superior Court during the sentencing in his felony assault case against Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/POOL/Rick LOOMIS (Photo credit should read RICK LOOMIS/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown smiles inside the Los Angeles Superior Court during the sentencing in his felony assault case against Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/POOL/Rick LOOMIS (Photo credit should read RICK LOOMIS/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown smiles inside the Los Angeles Superior Court during the sentencing in his felony assault case against Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/POOL/Rick LOOMIS (Photo credit should read RICK LOOMIS/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown leaves the Los Angeles Superior Court after sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown leaves the Los Angeles Superior Court after sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown (C) arrives at the Los Angeles Superior Court before sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown (C) arrives at the Los Angeles Superior Court before sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Singer Chris Brown (2nd L) leaves the Los Angeles Superior Court after sentencing in his felony assault case against fellow singer and former girlfriend Rihanna, on August 25, 2009. Brown was sentenced to five years probation and 1400 hours of community orientated labour. The incident shocked the music world and left Rihanna nursing cuts and bruises to her face, forcing her to cancel a scheduled performance at the Grammys in Los Angeles later that day. AFP PHOTO/Mark RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
Similar to the R. Kelly situation, I've noticed that many female music fans really don't care that Chris Brown is a man who seems to believe that it's O.K. to use a woman's face as a punching bag. The report that he used the big ring on his finger to inflict even more damage to Rihanna reminds you of the late Ike Turner. I hope he takes his domestic violence counseling seriously, since he can't go on living like this.
In the music industry, fans are quick to accept eccentric behavior from celebrities. The public took no issue with Michael Jackson's problematic relationships with children and there are many other scenarios in which a hit record is enough to take value judgments off the radar screen. Personally, I find myself in constant shock at the kind of language Lil Wayne's female fans allow him to use to consistently disrespect them. It almost seems that a polite Lil Wayne would not sell nearly as many records as the drunken, outlandish rapper who appears to have a serious drug problem.
Value systems aside and with the focus back on business, a black entertainer can rebuild his career after an arrest by doing the following things:
1) Just say that Jesus healed you. People always buy that one. It worked for R. Kelly. References to God, even when insincere and blatantly hypocritical, invoke deeply entrenched sensibilities within African Americans. Personally, I need proof that you've really changed, not just your statement that Jesus came to you in a dream.
2) Sincerely apologize. People always love a good apology.
3) Make a really hot song. If people are dancing to your music, they usually forget that you might want to punch out their daughter or think that she's a garden tool. Unfortunate, but true.
4) Remember the truth: People really don't care that much about the celeb's personal life and are looking for an excuse to forgive him anyway. I recall speaking to someone who works for a major network, and I was in awe over how nonchalant she was about the R. Kelly situation. All she kept saying was, "Well, he ISSSS talented," as if his talent forgives him for any sin committed in the present, past or future. I bumped into a radio exec at a major station in Chicago and listened to him essentially say the same thing when explaining why his station adjusted its policy against playing R. Kelly music shortly after the allegations. The fact is that people just don't care.
Chris Brown's brand will remain strong in the music industry. From a business standpoint, it is also ironic that being arrested may actually be a "coming out" party for him, reinventing him for the world as the tough, borderline thug that many women seem to love (remember when Lauren London said she had a crush on Ol Dog from Menace to Society -- a man known for being the craziest gang banger in entertainment history?). These coming out parties are common, as you typically see young actresses do sexy magazine covers on their 18th birthday (i.e. when "Simply Raven" became "Sexy Raven" and when Rudy Huxtable played a prostitute in her latest film), or male entertainers trying to look mean and "tatted up" to break away from their good boy image (i.e. Lil Bow Wow....I mean, Bow Wow). It's all about branding. The craziest thing about the Chris Brown situation is that being arrested for beating a woman could actually work to his advantage. So, our adoration for Chris Brown (actually, other people's adoration, since I don't respect any man who would do that to a woman) is a reflection of our society and a nasty look in the mirror for all of us. I should say, however, that I consider Chris Brown to be far different from R. Kelly: He is still a very young man who makes mistakes and could possibly become a decent adult with guidance and significant intervention -- which spoiled celebrities seldom receive.
Don't be surprised to see Chris hanging out with more rappers, where it's actually a good thing to be arrested. He's going to have a few more tattoos, a meaner "mug" on his next album and present a brand that embraces the hardcore image, yet not so hardcore that you won't believe him when he sincerely apologizes and says that Jesus saved him. The new Chris Brown will be interesting.
Follow BV on Money on Twitter!
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Distinguished Scholar with the Barbara Jordan Institute for Policy Research. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email, please click here.


Comments: (24)
Add a comment
By: Bro. Lee on 8/28/2009 1:11PM
Wow, I sence sarcasm.
I think you maybe emotionally attached.
The two of them should not be together they bring the wrong things out of each other it seems.
Remember Bonnie and Clyde?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: realtalk on 8/28/2009 2:38PM
in the near future boyce watkins closet will be opened and his past and possibly present will be revealed. most people like him are hypocrites.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: tykete on 8/28/2009 3:24PM
Only 5 years - if he beat a white woman you know he would have got more!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Marsha on 8/28/2009 6:59PM
personally, I think Dr. Boyce's comments are dead on the money!! I would further add that we as a community (the Black community) need to start calling our celebrity brothers and sisters to the carpet for blatantly irresponsible behavoir!! I speak specifically of Lil Wayne here who seems to be proud of the fact that he has four "baby mamas". I give anyone space to have indiscretions, but my goodness, where do we draw the line?? If we can get offended when white people offend our commnunity, then we need to be even more offended by our "self inflicted wounds"!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Valentino M. on 9/05/2009 11:23AM
OMG - So, so true. To our detriment, we stand by our own, enter OJ Simpson. Ask any black person today, and he/she will exclaim, "hell yeah, he's guilty!" When that case was fresh, no black person would've said that. His entire trial was a debacle: a crooked cop, an inept judge and an attorney who gave in to the media's dressing down of her already dressed-down look. Therefore, I understand why it went and had to happen the way that it did. We as a community don't properly, if at all, punish our brothers and sisters when they do wrong things. It's as if the legal and moral codes are different in our community.
Regarding R. Kelly, I have heard and can still hear other black persons say "That girl was a ho. She knew what she was doing. R. Kelly is a man." I agree that she might've been a little loose and obviously not new to sex, but R. Kelly should've been the MAN, the force who took charge to run her hot ass out of his room? He was never really given him any flack for that, because that sort of thing happens a great deal in the black community. It's not looked upon as statutory rape. It's simply dismissed as "a-hot-girl-getting-what-she-was-looking-for".
Now, as for Chris Brown: he made a stupid mistake and will deservedly be forgiven for it. I say deservedly, because he is young and dumb and we all have done and will do more stupid things before we're too old to blame youth and inexperience; granted all of us have not beaten up women. The stupid boy is getting exacly what he deserves. I have no remorse for him, but I do think he should be forgiven after he proves he is rehabilitated and sicerely apologetic, unike that mechanical, business-first youtube apology.
Report This
By: Ellie on 8/29/2009 1:28PM
Hopefully, Chris Brown will stay away from R. Kelly. He has enough problems; he doesn't need to add sex crimes to the list.
He needs to do his penance, take his anger management classes and learn from them and stay away from people who will get him in more trouble. That means staying away from the girlchild who helped him get into trouble in the first place (yes, she has some reponsibility too) and to stay away from known perverts, even IF their charges were dropped.
Chris Brown should use this time to grow-up, get to know himself better and decide what his priorities are in life. He should take advantage of counseling opportunites for himself in addition to the anger management classes. He is young, he can get past this and if he is truly talented, there will still be plenty of time to make music. He has a chance to become stronger and better man who mentally and emotionally stable; this fiasco does not have to be the defining moment of his life.
I wish him well.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Tina on 8/30/2009 10:38AM
Yes, I agree that Chris Brown does need help and because he is young he can hopefully pull away from this vicious cycle. He doesn't need R. Kelly either but I think R. Kelly was used to say look how he is still a success after all the issues he had, not for Chris to team up with him. As for these men preying on young girls... where I am from mothers encourage it and have no issues with it. The older women even hook up with the young boys and it is accepted. No one is stepping in to stop that. It seems you have to be a celebrity for them to even notice or show concern. I have always told my child a role model is someone you can talk to, touch, call and that you know has your best interest at heart not someone he sees on T.V. or has a number one CD. Our kids don't know these people and some of them are living foul in their personal lives they just got the money to cover it up so we don't know all the bad stuff. How can they even think they are role models! But I appreciate the discussion girl!!!!
Report This
By: Tina on 8/29/2009 8:54PM
Where is all this concern for women in the hood? If Chris Brown or R. Kelly weren't celebrities no one would be saying anything. Where's Dr. Boykin's at when in the inner city young girls being with older men happens daily and it's accepted. As well as women getting beat down. R. Kelly does make good music.... his personal life is his just as mine is mine. He is not a role model for my child so I could care less. Neither is Chris Brown. Us regular people are down here trying to survive we have better things to be concerned with other than how R. Kelly, Chris Brown or even Michael Vick live their lives. Get over it!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Ellie on 8/30/2009 10:25AM
You are absolutely correct in saying that these celebrities are not and should not be role models for our children. It is up to the parents to be the role model and to make accessible to their children the kinds of people that they would want them to emulate. I also feel, that it is the parent's responsibility(mine did and it almost went as far as jail time) to step in and stop these "old" men from preying on our young girls; if this means jail for the old man, tough. You appear to be doing what you need to do and I am sure you will continue. You are also correct, however, in stating that people like Dr. Boyce don't always address the nitty-gritty issues such as the old man/young girl issue. I guess it is not big enough news for them; wait until it touches their family, it will suddenly become a "big, new" issue.
But this question was about Chris Brown. He has had enough bad influences in his life, he does not need R. Kelly (I don't care if the charges were dropped) around him unless he is expanding into sex crimes. I hope for his sake, that his problems will force him to be more circumspect about his choice of companions in life.
Report This
By: Ellie on 8/30/2009 10:45AM
Thank-you for the response.
I wouldn't want to be a young person now, for love or money; especially if you don't have someone(parents, hopefully) who truly has your best interests at heart. I think I was very lucky.
Report This