I am going to say some things that will take money out of the pockets of people like myself. But darn it, it has to come out. I have taught MBA and undergraduate business students for the last 16 years, at many major universities. I believe strongly in the value of black entrepreneurship and I believe in the power of compassionate capitalism. The problem, however, is that there are times when I wonder about the power of an MBA. Fenorris Pearson, a successful black entrepreneur, has shared the same concerns, and I can't say I disagree with him completely.

Here's the deal. An MBA can be a powerful tool to learn how to manipulate your way through the complexities of corporate America. Most programs teach you how to analyze charts, create spreadsheets and do all the little things that your boss is going to ask you to do. The problem, however, is that the vast majority of professors teaching MBA courses at major institutions have never actually done the work they are teaching you to do.

An MBA student at an Ivy League institution recently told me that when he asked his professors how to actually implement the strategies that they were teaching on the chalk board, the responses from professors were always disappointing. The student aspires to be an entrepreneur, where being able to do something matters far more than your educational background. In fact, entrepreneurship is the ultimate test of your business skill: If you can't do the job, your academic credentials aren't going to help you win customers. Someone buying your product doesn't care if you have a Harvard MBA; they only care if you are giving them good service for a fair price.

The reason that university professors in many business schools across America have become ineffective at transmitting necessary tools to their students is that campuses have turned toward a commitment to research over practical skill building. Publishing complex research papers in journals that almost no one reads becomes the Ivory Tower's elitist way of proving that they are better than you and that they don't actually have to care if you aren't getting what you need to be successful. The MBA becomes a bought and sold commodity, where any student who can cough up the cash is almost certain to walk out of the institution with a piece of paper in his/her hand. While this doesn't define all MBA programs, it's hard to find anyone who would not argue that there is not some degree of grade inflation.

The professor you ask to help you find a job sometimes can't do a thing because he has few contacts in industries in which he has no experience. The faculty member who is asked if he has seen his models used in practice can only show you his publication in the Journal of Finance. University faculty have become as weak and complacent as special interests in the health care system when it comes to remaining committed to an ineffective educational process that takes care of the few individuals in power. It won't be until more practical models of education become preferred by society that university faculty will finally get the point. What is saddest is that many black scholars in business have also bought into the elitist "look, but don't touch the public" model of scholarship, leading many of our greatest minds to rot away their potential. I am not being critical of their achievements; rather, I am encouraging them to not be afraid to leave the intellectual plantation.

When it comes to the MBA, the bottom line is this: MBAs can be good for alumni networking and they are good for certification that allows you to obtain a position with a company. They may not, however, be very good at actually showing you how to start and run a successful company. You might get a better education on Google.com.


Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Finance Professor at Syracuse University and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money." To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.