I've always had mixed feelings about Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke. I feel that he is better than the previous chairman, Alan Greenspan, but the Fed Chairmanship (like the presidency) is almost never given to the right man. Just the fact that it is almost always given to a man is problematic enough, and the truth is that only white men need apply for the job.
Well, when you are limited in your option pool for the top job, bad leadership and flat out ignorance can sometimes be the result. While Fed Chairman Bernanke might know some nuts and bolts about economics, he appears to be shockingly misinformed about economic disparities between blacks and whites. His embarrassing and highly inappropriate statements at Morehouse College serve as a significant case in point.
In a recent interview at Morehouse, the Fed Chairman was asked what he felt to be the reason for the wealth gap between blacks and whites. In response, Bernanke said that the gap was due to a lack of "financial literacy" and "financial education" on the part of African Americans. That's all he mentioned.
What? Sorry Ben, but did you ever hear of this little thing called "slavery"? What about this other thing called "Jim Crow laws," which made it nearly impossible for African Americans to pass wealth onto their children? Wealth disparities are not created in a day, as inheritance levels (which vary substantially for whites and blacks) not only change your starting point in life, but also have a significant impact on your trajectory.
According to the 2007 Survey of Consumer Finances, the median household wealth of white Americans is 10 times greater than that for African-Americans. Additionally, other forms of inheritance, such as access to managerial positions, education and business ownership are far more likely to accrue to whites than African Americans. For example, Bill Gates claims that his wealth was self-made, but his mother was connected with board members at IBM, who gave him his first major contract. So, statistically speaking, if Bill Gates had been born a black man, he would not be a billionaire today. And in spite of what the Fed Chairman might believe, wealth disparities are not due to the fact that black people are financially ignorant. Rather, they are due to leaders such as Bernanke who refuse to acknowledge how 400 years of racially-biased wealth distribution can impact structural and financial inequality.
The other point that Mr. Bernanke fails to mention is that white American saving and investing habits are incredibly problematic as well. The recent financial crisis was due to the fact that the American savings rate had become negative for the first time since the Great Depression. Additionally, Americans (not just black people Ben) were borrowing money for homes they could not afford and not preparing for retirement. So, the idea that Chairman Bernanke would sum up the black/white wealth gap as "White people smart....black people illiterate" is a shocking disappointment and a glaring reminder of the fact that our economic captains in the Obama Administration have almost no understanding or respect for the unique economic challenges of the African American community.
I won't even get into Obama's appointment of Lawrence Summers as the Head of the National Economic Council, given that Summers disrespected Dr. Cornel West, one of the most significant black scholars in American history. During a spat when Summers was president of Harvard, he criticized Dr. West's work as not representing "appropriate" scholarship. Translation: you are doing something that white scholars don't understand, which thus implies that you must be inferior -- I get it all the time here at Syracuse, a school that hasn't tenured a black man in Finance in their entire 140-year history. Professor Summers is also the one who implied that women might have a natural deficiency in their ability to understand mathematics. Back to the point made earlier about inheritances of social and financial capital, Summers is the nephew of Paul Samuelson, who won the Nobel Prize in Economics. Do you REALLY believe that Summers would be in the position he is in had his uncle not won the Nobel Prize? No. Some might consider him to be a moderately intelligent version of George W. Bush.
The idea that Obama supports individuals who continue to embrace mindsets reflective of white male supremacy should be problematic to us all. The financial team within his administration needs a makeover, and their "expertise" and qualifications should be questioned by the American people. This is not to undermine the president or his ambitious goal of helping our country out of a recession. But it must be honestly and accurately noted that it's no coincidence that members of his economic team are so inclined to bail out wealthy white men on Wall Street and appear to have almost no concern for struggling black men on Martin Luther King Boulevard.
A note to Chairman Bernanke: The present around us has been created by a set of tasks that were performed in the past. If you are only able to see wealth disparities through a lens created in the year 2009, one that is blurred by your own biases as a white male in an elitist profession, you are missing 99% of the picture. To cite African American ignorance as the sole driver of wealth gaps in America is a reminder that our leadership still thinks of black people as second class citizens. Rather than presuming cultural superiority on the part of whites, why not engage in creative and intelligent policy analysis that might actually fix the problem that America has created? It was not the flaws of black America that created structural inequality; it was poor decision-making on the part of the very institutions that employ men like Bernanke and Summers over more qualified women and minorities who deserve equal access to those positions. It's time for some personal responsibility - black people didn't create racial inequality in America.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Finance Professor at Syracuse University and author of the forthcoming book, "Black American Money." To have Dr Boyce commentary delivered directly to your email, please click here. 




Comments: (21)
Add a comment
By: SARA on 11/01/2009 4:18PM
It's not a shock at all that a person of Bernankes' position will make sure myopic statement. Believe me Dr. Watkins, you should see what's going on in the mortgage financing now. Lenders are now going above and beyond to filter out blacks when you submit a loan. You can see their attitudes , they're still harboring distaste for blacks, therefore, they're coming up with outrageous rules and guidelines that are questionable. But then who will question them, when souls like Bernanke who is at the top of the financial regulations have this type of disturbing mindset. I see it everyday, the attitude of lenders towards minorities, especially blacks is disturbing to say the least.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Devon on 11/01/2009 7:50PM
Being an African American that works in the financial industry, I agree with your points on the reasons for the disparities. These issues where intentionally set to keep the status quo and by looks of things, they done a pretty good job of doing so. Mr. Bernanke knows that he can't really say the true reasons for these disparities, so he says what's easiest and/or most accepted by the mainstream. How can he not mention the fact that there's still racial discrimination in all facets of the American society that continue to keep us down. However, financial ignorance is "one" of the reasons and does need to be addressed. If we don't know the way we can't go that way.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: TYRONE on 11/01/2009 9:39PM
You need to get over yourself about the slavery bullcrap! There were WHITE slaves too.......so that issue is soooooooo played out and boring! Secondly, blacks are given their own colleges,pagents,etc..........just shut you all up! That isn't enough so.....just face it and this was created and will end a WHITE MAN'S WORLD!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: monique on 11/04/2009 8:11AM
You are a racist and part of the reason that ignorance continues to prevail in our society.
Report This
By: The Firefighter on 11/04/2009 9:34PM
You Idiot!!!
Report This
By: sgwhiteinfla on 11/01/2009 10:50PM
I am just wondering Dr. Boyce if you ever actually saw what Ben Bernanke said or if you simply relied on what the blog you linked to said he said. I can promise you that I don't have much love for Ben Bernanke as I believe he was a key part of the problems leading into the financial crisis. However any fair watching of the actual question which was not, "the Fed Chairman was asked what he felt to be the reason for the wealth gap between blacks and whites."
Here is the link to video of the actual question and answer which are totally not how that blog nor you yourself described them Dr Boyce.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgxFkatwT-w
I highly suggest that you watch it and consider a retraction. While Bernanke may well be uninformed about the reasons for the wealth gap between minorities and whites this particular back and forth is not illuminative in that area. Part of responsibly criticizing someone is making sure that criticism is valid. I don't find that to be the case in this instance.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: monique on 11/02/2009 6:28AM
There is a leading economist at Duke who agrees with Dr. Watkins' point of view on this issue. Also, if you look at Obama's policies, he has never mentioned any targeted policies for African Americans. He only preaches at them on personal responsibility. Here is the link to what the Duke Economist had to say:
http://www.thegrio.com/2009/10/bernanke-ignores-history-of-black-and-white-wealth-rift.php
Report This
By: monique on 11/02/2009 6:28AM
I just watched your video and he says exactly what Dr. Boyce says that he said. What are you talking about?
Report This
By: pobaldy on 11/30/2009 9:46AM
thanks, sarge? after viewing the link, i think this was basically a non-issue. i felt as such after reading dr. boyce's intro. bernake does mention that the chasm is due in part to financial literacy, and the initial question seems to beg a question that should surprise no one.
also, the fed's overall broad task of monetary policy should have no part in macro-income redistribution.
Report This
By: Yvonne on 11/02/2009 10:29AM
I see you live in the 51ST state called "Denial," blaming "De White Man" for our problems.It's now 2009 and it's time that we discard this ideology because this is old news. Maybe if we start looking at "De Black Folks" for a majority of our problems we would not have as many.
I don't find his comments to be racist, true but not racist. Maybe you do because of your own racist mind-set. The wealth disparity between "us and them" exist because we don't believe in investing like they do, because we'd rather wear our investments for others to see, such as:designer clothing, shoes, hair and cars. We believe in the now and no one is thinking about the later(Legacy) and they still want to spend their last dollars looking good in a coffin.
The only one investment that most people think they're making is by paying church tithes and the only ones who are seeing a return on that investment are the preachers. Investing is gambling with your money, but we'll make an investment at any casino within a 500 mile radius to take our chances on hitting the jackpot.
The gap exist because more people aren't motivated to obtain a higher education into fields which pay them well to possibly invest in leaving legacy's.
The gap exist because after desegregation, our money, our pride, and our self-respect left with it. We stopped creating real wealth during that time, but instead continued creating it for others, something which we are still doing to this very day.
We don't invest in our own communities, we're not creating opportunities for our people to prosper because the majority of us, even the so called educated ones like yourself are of the slave mind-set. We're still waiting for "De White Man" to do it for us because they brought us here and they're still responsible for us because they owe us.
Commentary like this is nothing but a way to arouse individuals like yourself into anger which again does nothing but further perpetuate the problem. The same old lip service and the stagnation of victim-hood does nothing but leaves us back at square one.
Those within our group with the wealth have the means to create opportunities by setting up various training programs, which then can turn into jobs, which then can turn into businesses that conduct business all over the world. But instead of doing that, they'll throw a little philanthropy toward the people and wait on the government to pick up the slack.
As with everything about our acceptance from others, when we start respecting our money, maybe others will do the same. Until then we'll continue being the worlds largest ATM's and continue providing hedge fund money to others because we don't have the time to learn investment strategy's or read a book.
The responsibility now lies with us to change our circumstances. You can best empower and inspire our people by telling them the truth. We can succeed without being a victim and victims don't leave legacies, they leave debt, only empowered men and women leave a legacy for their children and their community. And yes I am leaving a legacy for my children worth over a Million dollars on a $50,000 a year salary.
Reply to this Comment | Report This