Jean addresses allegations that his charity misused funds in a recent video, and says that the charity will assist victims in Haiti. "Let me be clear: I denounce any allegation that I have ever profited personally through my work with Yele Haiti," Jean said in a statement released Saturday. "These baseless attacks are simply not true."
I spent the weekend thinking long and hard about my position on Wyclef Jean's organization, since I am not one to buy right into anyone's hype one way or the other. I wasn't quick to believe Wyclef, and I wasn't quick to believe those who are likely a bit jealous and dumbfounded that a black man runs one of the most popular charities during a crisis of this magnitude. Here are some thoughts on the Wyclef Jeane "Yele Haiti" situation:
1) I am going to keep supporting Wyclef Jean. I don't know Wyclef Jean personally, but I love what he is trying to do. Not only did I make a donation to Yele Haiti, I also informed the 60,000 members of my YBW Coalition that I was making the donation. I also plan to make donations to other groups, such as Doctors without Borders, since I believe in spreading my money around. I made my donation to Wyclef's charity because several conversations with individuals who know Wyclef personally lead me to believe that he is genuinely concerned with the well-being of Haiti. I listen to my friends before I believe some article I read on the Internet. Additionally, Wyclef makes a very good argument that his charity can get to those tough-to-reach neighborhoods far easier than other charities can.
2) Wyclef should stop paying himself to perform for his own organization: When I read that Wyclef paid himself $100,000 out of his charity for a benefit concert, I was concerned. One can argue that good charity starts at home, so the $100,000 in performance fees could have and should have gone to the Haitian people. You can pay yourself to perform (since the brother has bills, I'm sure), but you can't give yourself $100,000 for one concert and then attempt to argue that the amount was below market value.
3) Many of the expenditures from Yele Haiti were justifiable: I am not one to say that there is a legitimate reason behind every expenditure made by Yele Haiti, but further investigation is necessary before we decide that the expenses are a waste of money. For example, thousands spent on production costs for Wyclef's studio might come from the fact that the artist has used his music as a tool to promote Haitian causes. To presume that he is some kind of crook for making these investments would be silly.
4) Don't forget about racism: Understand that it is quite rare for a young black man to single-handedly engage in such massive amounts of goodwill. This task is likely overwhelming for Wyclef, implying that he might make mistakes along the way. If he does make those mistakes, it's very easy for a racist nation like the US to decide that this black man must be a crook. Not only are some attempting to imply that Wyclef Jean might have stolen money, but that he also lacks the expertise necessary to get the aid to the people who need it. This is a subtle, yet incredibly condescending reminder that many Americans still think that only white people know how to run effective organizations. I dismiss that notion entirely.
5) Wyclef Jean needs to hire some experts: Your charity is on the big stage now Wyclef. Given the legitimate questions that have been raised about your organization, it is critical that you hire the necessary experts to ensure that everything is above board. The magnitude of Wyclef's organization is now calling for increased scrutiny by groups designed to monitor charities for fraudulent behavior, so it is important that his team include individuals who can ensure that the organization is run efficiently and effectively. Once these individuals are hired, Wyclef should keep issuing statements to tell his supporters that he has made necessary adjustments to make sure that their funds are being put to good use. When it comes to saving Haiti, NO ORGANIZATION ON EARTH has the passion and commitment toward the Haitian nation that Wyclef Jean has consistently shown through "Yele Haiti." That is a simple fact. So, while Wyclef may not be perfect, his heart is targeted toward caring for the people he loves. He just may need to channel that passion in a more careful and organized way.
When it comes to Wyclef Jean and Yele Haiti, the bottom line is this: I am not here to say that there is no corruption in this organization. But I can say that nearly everyone I've spoken to has vouched for Wyclef's love for Haiti, even if his organization has not meticulously accounted for every penny he has collected. Additionally, I have more trust for charitable organizations run by those who truly love Haiti than I have for organizations run by well-intended groups that are going to disappear once the crisis is over. Wyclef has stood for Haiti, represented Haiti to the fullest, and will continue to stand with Haiti once all the other groups have left the country. This man deserves my support, and you may want to consider giving him yours as well. Don't believe all the hype you read in the media - it can sometimes be deceptive.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 




Comments: (20)
Add a comment
By: Roberson Lapierre on 1/18/2010 10:38AM
Thank you Wyclef for all you do. Too many people are just talking and doing nothing, but ready to criticize those really helping. We need to step up and be a force instead of questioning and discouraging those helping during these times. We need more Wyclef Jean out there and less critics. I need the means to go there and help hands on if possible, but I can't get there.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Drew on 1/21/2010 11:08AM
Wyclef has been working for several years on trying to improve the conditions of Haiti. He called for Haitian people around the world to come back and improve the community. He's sunk a lot of his own money, time, effort and heart into projects.
I read reports that he even went to Haiti to pull dead and living people from rubble.
I know there are great concern for scam artists in this day and age. And evil people do try and profit from war, disaster and suffering of others.
My only concern would be that Yele Haiti is more of a long term program than being able to provide short term relief. (I'm not sure of their organizational makeup) But either way, I'm confident of their intention.
I think the best advice, like the columnist said, donate to a variety of charities. You don't need to put all your eggs in one basket, just open your heart and donate what you can to the different emergency, relief and long term organizations.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: valery on 1/18/2010 2:40PM
I do not trust this fundation at all, and in this difficult time many people are trying to take advantage of Haiti, and i don't really know what the yele does in Haiti. So people who donated now its time to ask where your money goes and what they have done with it, they need to provide details, and God only knows if my dear country will be able to stand up again.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: BIBI on 1/18/2010 2:46PM
First off I bet your one of the many that just sit back and make comments when you your self aint doin a damn thing for Haiti. How much have you help lately??? Unless you've helped then please keep your discourageing comments to your self and help this man support your so called Haiti.
Yele has been in Haiti before this earthquake hit and will remain in Haiti. Where were you at? And where will you be??? Exactly Handleing your business. So please research before you start acting as if you care so much for Haiti.
Report This
By: drobin on 1/18/2010 3:30PM
If you do not trust Wyclef charitable organization, it is your right not to donate. It is somewhat ironic the timing of this article, if there was suspension about this organization,my question would be, why did it come out just last week? It is also important to remember, the sourse of this of these charges, The Smoking Gun, which is owned by Time Warner.
It would only be fair to show all the CEO's income, not just Wyclef. Below is an important paragraph to read and the website address you can go to for more information on the salaries of some of the major charitable organization CEO, who are receiving federal funds.
Of the charities on our site, there are 93 charities that accept government funding and also pay their CEO $500,000 or more. These organizations include: Boys & Girls Clubs of America, American Red Cross (recipient of a $100 million government bailout), Easter Seals, March of Dimes, and the American Cancer Society. Of these 93 charities, 33 accept more than $100 million in government funding and pay their CEO $500,000 or more. These organizations include: Stanford University, Harvard University, The New York Public Library, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute and Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
http://blog.charitynavigator.org/2009/02/non-profit-ceo-pay-and-government.html
Report This
By: valery on 1/18/2010 3:18PM
This has been a great concern for many of the Haitian community. Whyclef is a great person no doubt about it. I want him to answer that question he is the CEO of Telemax why he choose to buy advertisement of his charity in his own network that is not fair to me and $250.000 US I am not buying it. He has some more explanation to do. Haiti always been that way, he receives so much from America and others for I am really greatful but nothing ever changes. Now the time has come for change. Haitian people together let raise our voices for the sake of our country, we need accountable people enough is enough...
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: TOM K. BUNCH on 1/18/2010 4:13PM
This guy has done what most heads of states have asked all of us to do and that's to help others, now if he has taken money, that's wrong.But haven't the best done it themself's? Not saying it's ok,people are dying and greed is poping up it's ugly head once more. Stop it, just stop it and try to be human dam.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: sherridina on 1/19/2010 11:03AM
Wyclef John is, probably, the most famous Haitian-American. He is proud of where is from and has been helping Haiti since long before the earthquake. I believe his heart is in the right place.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: JR on 1/19/2010 8:36PM
I wonder how much he made from the concert in comparison to the $100,000 he paid himself.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Rick davis on 1/19/2010 9:27AM
I wouldn't give this crooked monkey one dime of my money to use for his personal gain. And I'm black.
If you want to make a donation do it with the Red Cross. No they may not be perfect but no one can denie they are there for people all over the world in their time of need.
Reply to this Comment | Report This