National Review's Black Unemployment Panel Had No Black Experts on It

Comments (4)

The National Review is known for being a conservative and some think, racist publication. Their recent actions didn't do much to dispel that claim, when they put together a panel to discuss black unemployment. Gawker.com noted that their panel consisted of a nice list of experts from various walks of life, but not one single black person in the group. The panelists were asked to focus on racial inequality in America, and they also seemed to be promoting racial imbalance by not giving a voice to African Americans.

One of the topics the panelists were asked to discuss was black unemployment, which has skyrocketed this month. Even though white American unemployment has stabilized at 8.8%, black unemployment shot up from 15.8% to 16.5% during the month of March. Black male unemployment is at 19% and black teen unemployment is 41%. The group's policy advisors had varying explanations for this problem, some of which were typical conservative rhetoric. Some of the ideas, however, were not all that bad.

"The key to lifting the economic fortunes of African Americans (and perhaps a clue to the persistent gap in employment) is imbuing an entrepreneurial ethic, and providing a policy climate, that allows them to offset the negative impacts of racial discrimination using their own skills and aptitudes. While rising tides do in fact lift all boats, falling tides can strand many of these boats on the beach. This is playing out in the Great Recession," said Samuel R. Staley, Robert W. Galvin Fellow and director of Urban & Land Use Policy at the Reason Foundation.

I agree with Mr. Staley about entrepreneurship being important for the black community. By creating our own jobs, we do not have to worry about others taking our jobs away from us. Part of the reason black people struggle in bad economies is that in a country that struggles with racism and sexism, people are going to protect the jobs of those with whom they identify. This can be described as racism, but it may just be favoritism.


One of the prevailing themes of the experts' analysis of black unemployment is that many of them seemed to argue that racism does still exist. But their main point is that while racism is real, it is not as pervasive as others try to say it is. They explain that when racial disparities exist, it is not always due to racism. Instead, they argue that the disparities may exist because big government has crippled the black community or African Americans do not always have the same skills as whites.

Roger Clegg, General Counsel for The Center for Equal Opportunity, refers to policies such as Affirmative Action as being racism that causes more racism. Whether you agree with Clegg or not usually depends on whether you are conservative or liberal. The liberal point of view is that the racism of the past requires remedies that directly link to actions that will alleviate the impact of that racism. But if you only see the action itself and not the reason for the action, it is very easy to argue that Affirmative Action is racist. I do not agree with Clegg's position.

What clearly appears to be true is that the National Review should have included at least one black policy expert on their panel, which would have been the right thing to do. While they did have some good ideas, you can't fight racism by being racially exclusive.

Lawrence Watkins is the CEO of The Great Black Speakers Bureau and an MBA student at Cornell University. For more information, please visit LawrenceWatkins.com.

Comments: (3)

Add a comment

Page 1 of 1

Add a Comment

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed but they are required to confirm your comments. When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password."

Most Commented Articles

Daily Drama

The Best Clips From TV's Hottest Shows


More Daily Drama >>

Find a Message Board

Discover conversations on everyone from Barack to Beyonce. There are nearly 50 forums, so click on a category below and find the right one for you.