
In fact, the Society for Human Resources Management reports that 60 percent of employers do credit checks on applicants, up from 13 percent in 1996. Needless to say, the growing number of credit checks couldn't come at a worse time for those seeking employment. The tough economy has put millions of people in dire financial straights. As more Americans have missed credit card payments, been late on their mortgages or failed to keep up with hefty medical bills, their credit has suffered.
As I point out in my new book, 'Perfect Credit: 7 Steps to a Great Credit Rating,' even tens of millions of consumers who've managed to pay their bills on time during the Great Recession have seen their credit scores decline -- simply because banks have cut their credit limits. Fair Isaac, the creator of the FICO credit score, recently reported that about one in five Americans have bad credit scores of 599 or lower. (FICO scores range from 300 to 850.)
Although employers don't get your credit score when they do a credit check on you, they nonetheless gain access to all sorts of personal details about your financial life, such as:
* A list of every creditor you owe
* Past credit obligations
* The balances and monthly payments you make on all credit accounts (student loans, car payments, housing, etc.)
* The size of your credit card limits
* Whether you're listed as an "authorized user" on someone else's account or have joint credit accounts
* Public records, such as bankruptcies, judgments or overdue child support payments
* Collections, charged off accounts and accounts closed by your creditors
Are such credit checks fair or even necessary? Employers say yes. They say someone who has managed their financial affairs responsibly is likely to also be responsible in the workplace. Employers also contend that credit checks can point out red flags that might not otherwise be apparent just by looking at someone's resume or interviewing them.
I understand employers' concern. No one wants to add a problem employee to the payroll, someone so financially desperate that they might steal money from the company.At the same time, I'm not at all convinced that credit checks are a legitimate screening tool for determining who'll be a great employee and who won't. Plus, most employees won't be dealing with company or customer money in the routine course of their jobs.
Perhaps that's why three states -- Oregon, Hawaii and Washington -- have banned employment-related credit checks, and 16 other states and the District of Columbia are trying to do the same thing. Moreover, federal legislation is also pending to end the credit checks.
In my opinion, credit checks in the workplace are overly intrusive and don't serve their stated purpose. With unemployment at 9.5 percent, and roughly six applicants vying for every one job position available in the United States, we don't need to throw up additional roadblocks to Americans finding the jobs to support their families.
Has bad credit ever cost you or someone you know a job? Tell your story or share your thoughts about this topic.
Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, an award-winning financial news journalist and former Wall Street Journal reporter for CNBC, has been featured in the Washington Post, USA Today, and the New York Times, as well as magazines ranging from Essence and Redbook to Black Enterprise and Smart Money. Check out her New York Times best seller 'Zero Debt: The Ultimate Guide to Financial Freedom.'
Comments: (34)
Add a comment
By: Cheryl on 8/04/2010 6:54AM
I was told that I had a job at a very prominent financial company here in Canada. They apparently did this before they did their credit check, as after they checked my info the woman came back and told me they cannot move forward with me. She also denied she told me I was being offered the job. I wish the confirmation of the job offer was in an e-mail format as I would more than likely consulted an employment attorney. I gave up another job offer in favour of the one I was eventually rejected from.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Cheryl on 8/05/2010 9:39AM
I want to get my original comments removed as the replies are only from spammers.
Report This
By: angela7 on 8/06/2010 2:58AM
Don't worry Cheryl, it's their lost. Take heart in knowing it's best you didn't take the job afterall; most likely would not have turned out well. You'll find another or better yet, creat your own.
Report This
By: RDR on 8/04/2010 9:13AM
There are more rich people who steal than any poor people I know. Those are the ones you have to keep your eyes on. Every person who's in dire financial straits isn't a thief. When my credit was bad when I was in my 20's, the last thing on my mind was stealing from someone. A thief is a thief, rich or poor.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: stare k on 8/04/2010 1:07PM
You are 200% right .I know of a nice nice lady . Shw told every thing on her co- worker .Nice home , nice car .I knew any thing she had gotten fried for stealing ,she was a cashier @ one of the big hospitals . Taking money every day , Had worked there for 22 yrs. I just have to tell u yes she was WHITE. Remember They never steal just blacks do things like that . (MADOFF).
Report This
By: LaDy on 8/05/2010 10:51PM
I infinitely agree with you! One's employment history should be the deciding factor; criminal background checks but certainly not how you pay your bills!!!
Report This
By: john johnson on 8/04/2010 10:55AM
this practice is buII$h!t! how the hell do you expect to pay back your creditor without a dam job!?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: barbarascy385 on 8/04/2010 11:51AM
This is just another form of discrimination. A lot of people's credit took a hit because of job loss. Now when they are trying to get back on their feet they are hit with this practice. I can see doing this kind of check on somebody who works for a bank or has a job that requires a certain level of security concerning money. But to get a job at your average minimum wage job I say no. Besides a criminal background check would be a better and more accurate telling of a person's history. With credit checks you don't really know what the story is behind any blemishes on credit. The way a lot of these companies are run today they may have made a mistake on someone's credit report. You just can't judge somebody based on a credit report. Besides if a potential employee asks for a company's credit report would they get it? Probably not.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: wickedmercedez on 8/05/2010 5:43PM
i work in banks for 6 years, and have been truened down because of my credit which was ruined due to my idenity being stolen. so because my credit was messed up i shouldnt have been able to work in a bank? that i wouldnt be able to do my job effectively? so only people with good credit deserve the good job? is that what you are saying?
Report This
By: Fashionedbygod33 on 8/04/2010 12:09PM
I agree with the author and the views expressed by the posters thus far. I just cannot believe the times we are in. This is really sad. Most people do not want to be in excessive debt or have poor credit but if a person cannot secure a job, then how is that situation supposed to improve? I really hope these laws get passed and other states follow suit like Oregon, Hawaii, and Washington.
Reply to this Comment | Report This