
Pastor Soaries and Terry Williams join Soledad O'Brien in a discussion of 'ALMIGHTY DEBT: A BLACK IN AMERICA SPECIAL' airing on CNN on Thursday, October 21, 2010, 9pm EST.
I am not sure what to make of the whole "Black in America" series that CNN has promoted quite heavily since the Henry Louis Gates debacle last summer. I know that Soledad O'Brien is great to watch and incredibly capable and articulate. I do wonder, however, why CNN has chosen to put a microscope on all that is wrong with black people. Are they working to seek change? Are they trying to create public awareness? Are they using us for entertainment? I'm not sure what to think.
After watching a few clips of the upcoming show, which you can watch at this link, I noticed that there seems to be an effort by CNN to dig deeper into this intriguing institution called "the African American church." In one of the clips, they focus on a pastor who is teaching his congregation about the dangers of falling into debt. I agreed with much of what I saw, except I'm always trying to figure out why I hear some pastors talking about money more than I do. I figured that as a Finance Professor, talking about money was my job. I guess I was wrong.
I also noticed that in the "Almighty Debt" special, CNN took the additional step of bringing scholarly analysis into the fold. Dr. Julianne Malveaux did a wonderful job of explaining how slavery and Jim Crow contributed to the wealth disparities which exist right now. I was absolutely furious after seeing that in their last release of "Black in America," the producers mentioned the wealth disparities, but seemed to imply that this was simply a phenomenon that was born and raised in the African American community. It went back to the simple-minded notion that "Black people are poor because they are just not as disciplined as everyone else," thus feeding right into the beast of white supremacy.
I am hopeful that as CNN approaches this huge responsibility, they utilize their platform to educate the public on issues that matter, and also work to affect meaningful change. The last thing that African Americans need is yet another series designed to make fun of us. Additionally, if they are going to attack important topics like education, the criminal justice system and financial empowerment, leading black scholars in these fields should be consulted to ensure that the work is on track. The inclusion of Dr. Malveaux impressed me because she is a scholar with a strong knowledge of finance and economics. While it might be easy to presume that Dr. Malveaux's expertise is no different from the many financial advisors we see on television, the nasty truth is that Dr. Malveaux learned more in one semester of doctoral study than most of the other "experts" learned in four years of college. In fact, she and I both have taught thousands of students who are now considered to be financial experts themselves. This is not to minimize the depth of expertise that other public figures bring to the table, but I have to be honest and say that getting my PhD in Finance was the most difficult, yet insightful thing I've ever accomplished (my program took 400 applications and accepted only eight students. Many of them never graduated). I made this sacrifice in order to bring the knowledge back home to my people, and so did Dr. Malveaux.
If we are dealing with complex issues, we need complex minds. Racism is not a simple problem with simple solutions. I hope CNN remembers this when they are trying to get enough viewers to impress their corporate sponsors. I also applaud the fact that they seem to be genuinely interested in noting the disproportionate number of foreclosures, bankruptcies and job loss being experienced by black America. The Obama Administration should take a note as well, given that economic inequality will likely not go away without bold government intervention. We cannot remain silent about these issues.
Related:
+Soledad O'Brien Talks to Black Voices About 'Almighty Debt: A Black In America Special'
+Exclusive Preview: CNN's 'Black in America' to Tackle Debt Crisis
I'll be watching "Almighty Debt," and I expect it's going to be better than the last installment. At the very least, I am hopeful that we can grow and learn from the project and not find ourselves perpetually frustrated. I'll tell you what I think when it's done.
'ALMIGHTY DEBT: A BLACK IN AMERICA SPECIAL' will air on CNN on Thursday, October 21, 2010, 9pm EST.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action Resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 
Comments: (25)
Add a comment
By: stopthestupidity on 10/20/2010 9:25AM
When is Solidad and CNN going to do something in a positive light for African Americans. I and many others have stated the lack of positive middle class success stories seen on these specials. How about the thousands of college grads who are working and living good lives, married or single. How about the African American families run by single men taking care of their children while holding down jobs. How about those of us who live in great communities just like our other race counterparts and save money, pay our bills and have businesses. To look at these specials it is almost totally one sided and the rest of the functional working class and well to do African
Americans do not exist. Tell the whole story all of us are not down troden although we all do have to deal with racism and bigotry at times in our lives.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Jackie on 10/20/2010 10:00AM
Why did Dr. Boyce find it necessary to use this space to brag about his education. If you are writing about the CNN special, stick to the topic. I find Dr. Boyce a little cocky at times.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Ms. T on 10/22/2010 9:22AM
Yes, I agree. He seems just a little too self-congratulatory at times. I'm sick of how he needs to tell us that he's with his daughter or taking care of/supporting his child. Especially when it has no real relevance to the topic. It's like, "just do your job". My parents didn't have to drop in every conversation that they were doing what they were supposed to be doing as parents.
Report This
By: Tony Guillory on 10/24/2010 8:29PM
What are you talking about? Dr. Boyce wasn't 'bragging' about his ed. credentials. He's a very smart brother, who has earned his way in a in an area that we all need much education/information-finances. He's an expert in the field. Most importantly(as he clearly indicated), he has committed his work to educating his people/our people. Don't you get it??? So in the future, use what sounds like insecurity or intimidation with educated blacks, as energy to increase your knowledge AND affect change. Impact someone's life...like he does. And Finally, after watching the CNN special, I think all viewers should be asking the question: why wasn't Dr. Boyce a special guest? We would have all been better for it, if he had. I'm a huge fan of Dr. Boyce! We need more Dr. Boyces!!
Report This
By: taylor on 10/20/2010 11:07AM
Hey here's a suggestion
you don't like CNN's programming.....Don't watch it.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: taylor on 10/20/2010 11:18AM
I find him to be quite jealous of other successful African Americans. Must be something lacking on the inside.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Brady on 10/20/2010 11:40AM
"I'll be watching "Almighty Debt," and I expect it's going to be better than the last installment".
Not going to waste my time watching this. What are we a bunch of lab rats? There is no single cause for debt problems amongst a vast group of people.
Yes, slavery and Jim Crow has contributed, but with each passing generation it is and should have less of an effect. Thats just evolution, some folks grow and adapt others just wallow in the past.
From person to person the reasons vary for high degrees of debt, so no matter how educuated,or knowledable one appears to be, unless you talk to ever black person or a very wide sample of people, its speculation at best.
Regarding the disproportionate number of foreclosures and etc... It is disproportionate "partly" becuase the "Community Redevelopment Reinvestment Act" mandated that with government backing, people who otherwise couldnt qualify were provided mortgages. In short they cant afford a home but lets provide them a mortgage anyway.
sorry but thats what happened.
It was well intended, but we see how that worked out. So again we the reasons for debt and forclosure are complicated and varied.
Many folks think and really beleive Bush did this, when in "fact" all he did was continue a policy that begain under Carter, and sustained by Clinton. It just all feel apart under Bush.
Hell if they cant even get the facts straight about this, how are they can find the answer regarding something as complex as Black Debt.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kingdavidlives on 10/20/2010 7:15PM
Re:
Yes, slavery and Jim Crow has contributed, but with each passing generation it is and should have less of an effect.
Wrong! Wealth builds upon itself. If you own almost all of the wealth, how can I catch up with you? You can make a small annual return on such a large amount of wealth that I couldn't catch up if I had returns 10 times yours because that return would be on a smaller base of funds.
Report This
By: pat on 10/20/2010 12:34PM
I find it interesting that the clergy is talking about this considering that most sermons today are about obtaining material possessions and how this is a sign of God's blessing on one's life. The Bible is clear on how a man's life doesn't consist of his material possessions. I know lots of people that fell into debt b/c their preacher drilled into their heads that they needed a bigger home,luxury car,etc. I also find some preachers are changing this tune now b/c their own funds have dried up from congregants who have no large sums of money to give. Actually,hear some preachers saying now that if we can get the people to stop buying so much then they can bring the money to us. I won't be watching CNN on this issue b/c I already know what time it is.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: kingdavidlives on 10/20/2010 7:18PM
Everyone,
Paying tithes and offerings will at a minimum leave you with less money available to help your family and others. At a maximum, it could leave you broke and financially devastated.
People, study the Bible and learn the truth about these things. Keep your money for yourselves; don't give it to your pastors!!!
Report This