Just a few months ago First Lady Michelle Obama was being compared to Marie Antoinette because she wore a slamming off-the-shoulder designer top and some shades as she walked the cobble stone streets of Spain. Now she's being criticized for not evoking images of an elitist monarchy for the greedy social insiders of Washington, DC. The Politico news blog, in its latest screed against the First Lady, laments that Michelle Obama's White House doesn't remind DC insiders enough of "Camelot."
That's right -- the imaginary royal realm of Arthurian legend that many historians use metaphorically to describe the aura of the Kennedy administration. (We all know now what that was like in real life.) Her chief crime? Apparently not rubbing elbows with "the right kind of people" in Washington, DC -- basically the political wives and powerful influencers of the city. And how does Politico demonstrate that this decision makes Michelle Obama not queenly enough?
In a grand display of a complete and total lack of journalistic self awareness or history, Politico features a cluster of judgemental statements and subjective quotes from various high brow (as in, "who?") sources:
Sally Quinn? Who? Really, Politico. Really?
Was Michelle Obama "keeping to herself" when she was trudging around with school kids from Bancroft elementary, harvesting veggies in the White House garden? Was she "not inclusive" when she spent hours trumping along with hundreds of little ones dressed in their Sunday finest for the White House Easter Egg Roll -- many of whom would never have gotten an opportunity to participate if Michelle Obama had not democratized the ticketing process, allowing parents to obtain tickets online? And what of the First Lady's mentoring program? Was she "very funny socially" when she took a group of young girls to hang out with Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Sonya Sotomayor at the Supreme Court of the United States? I guess she wasn't "revitaliz[ing] some of the glamour of the White House" when she was hula hooping in the Ro Sham Bo Relay on the South Lawn at the White House Healthy Kids Fair -- but that's exactly her point.
The White House isn't a castle and the last time I checked, the American public wasn't looking to reinstate Camelot. It is the residence and headquarters for the executive branch of government. The whole point of the American ideal is that we aren't supposed to be a monarchy. We don't have kings and queens -- and the first lady socializes with us, not just the elite. Real people, ordinary people are "the right kind of people" to invite to the White House. And First Lady Michelle Obama has hosted the real people of America at her home in spades -- and different shades, as for the first time in recent history the White House has consistently hosted prominent African Americans and honored our various nationalities.
History will remember her as the first lady who re-opened the White House after the horrific attacks of 9/11. In the aftermath of the terrorists attacks on New York City, Washington, DC and Pennsylvania, the capital physically changed. Streets closed. Air traffic patterns were altered. Barricades went up. Access to the White House was severely restricted for ordinary Americans. Michelle Obama changed all that. She held over 300 public events there in the first 12 months of her tenure. In 2009 alone over 600,000 people visited the White House due to her amazing level of inclusive hospitality.
Keeping to herself? Come on. To put this complaint into perspective, the Bushes (as was their prerogative) did not throw a ton of social events during their time in the White House. In eight years in office, First Lady Laura Bush hosted six state dinners. Michelle Obama hosted two within her first 18 months. The only real jab that Politico is able to get in on Mrs. O is that many think the insiders' circle of politicians' wives found at cocktail parties with the "haves" is a critical part of how Washington business gets done -- and that it's her job as a political wife to help her husband make inroads towards forging these connections.
That may have been how political business used to get done -- but, the Obamas promised change, and that's what DC politicos are going to get as well. Their days of preferred access to the White House, president and first lady have come to a close.
Plus, the first lady knows that no matter what she does, the yapping chihuahuas of the elitist DC social scene will never be happy, so she's keeping the commitment she made at the beginning of her tenure to the American people. She knows that if ordinary Americans don't get access to the White House during her tenure, they may never get access again because the power elite who typically guards its entry appears to be under the delusion that only it comprises the "right kind" of people to have access to the White House and its occupants. And Politico.com is happy to be the whining mouthpiece of the DC power elite. It's a good thing First Lady Michelle Obama knows who she really works for.
If Washington, DC political and social elitists long for the days of a fictitious monarchy, I suggest they hop on their brooms and fly across the Atlantic and ask for an audience with Kate Middleton. Good luck getting inside Buckingham Palace!
Gina McCauley is the CEO of the Blogging While Brown Conferenceand the blogsMichelle Obama Watch and What About Our Daughters. She is currently completing her first book, 'Michelle Obama Watch.'


Comments: (19)
Add a comment
By: FRANK on 11/30/2010 2:09PM
SOCIAL ELITISM USING A BRITISH VALUE SYSTEM...IS PART OF WHAT HAS BEEN HORRIBLE IN WASHINGTON FOR TOO LONG.
BUT HEY, "REGARDLESS TO WHAT" MICHELLE DOES, IT WILL DISPLEASE MILLIONS OF PEOPLE, BECAUSE TOO MANY FOLKS CAN'T IDENTIFY WITH HER AS A WOMAN...
THEY SEE BLACK FIRST...
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: andrea on 12/01/2010 10:18AM
so true! people cannot see past the fact that we have an Awesome black family in office. they just cant accept it and therefore both the President and first lady will never be judged on an even scale with other presidencies.
Report This
By: justsaypmoe on 11/30/2010 6:51PM
well said.
as always...ignorance is bliss...
Report This
By: So4Real on 12/01/2010 9:50AM
This country is a total joke. The typical American possibly thought that Mrs. Obama would rush into the White House to ghettoize it. No one seems to be able to deal with the fact that this is an educated woman. One with ethics and morals. The fact that she's an African American is the cherry on the cake. We're so se to seeing first ladies being seen and not heard in a professional manner, that we obviosuly can't deal with the fact that we have a REAL WOMAN in the White House for a change. The media and its silly remarks about what she's waring, how her eyebrows were arched, how she conducts herself with the inner city children. Come on folks, give it a break. We have a power couple in the White House that no one can pinpoint any unethical boozing, partying or foolwanging too. And we cannot accept the fact that they're hanging tough. It still puzzles me how citizens of this country are still pointing the finger at President Obama for the mess he inherited, and folks have the gall to blame him for this mess we're in and simply cannot accept constructive change. Whenin actuality President Bush (both of them) dug us so deep in the hle that America became the laughing stock of the global community, and no one had a grudge about anythng then. Get it together people of America. Leave Mrs. Obama alone, be happy she's not afarid to stay true to herself as the woman she is and not some crafted, made over something. I love her, she's what African American women should look too for what we really are and can be.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: teddy knight on 12/02/2010 11:11PM
Your facts are correct, and I agree with your interpretation. What you are overlooking is that the same kind of "populist" revolt, with similar accusations that the President is a fake, is a liar, is a traitor, were mounted against every previous Democratic president. FDR was really a Jew named Rosenfeld, not from a Dutch family named Roosevelt who settled in the New York area when it was called New Amsterdam. And treason? Our natural allies were the Germans, but he forced us into siding with the English and French, then betrayed us to the Russians. His death was celebrated in large parts of the country. Truman murdered Roosevelt to succeed him, lied about the A-bomb and atomic energy, sold North Korea out to the Chinese Communists and betrayed South Korea when he fired MacArthur for refusing to obey orders, pimped his daughter for votes, etc. Kennedy lied about his marital status, he was divorced and remarried, Jackie was his 3rd "wife". He betrayed us over Cuba and over not turning the Cold War into a Hot War at every pretext. Remember the John Birch Society, the precursor of today's Tea Party, funded by the father of the Koch family. Again, his death was celebrated in many parts of the country. Carter was portrayed as a bumbling, falsely religious, coward. We remember what happened to Clinton. Despite his many accomplishments all that ever appeared in the U.S. news was his zipper problem. Then Obama, and the sons of old man Koch are pouring multiple millions into front organizations that fund the Tea Parties and fund churches that use their pulpits to preach political hatred. The battle cries are the same "preserve the constitution", except of course for those clauses and amendments that give other people rights, take back "our" country, as if 50 thousand middle aged people own the country, forget about the 600 million others who live here, etc. Oh, and Mrs. Roosevelt, Mrs. Truman, the daughter Sally, Jackie Kennedy and the children, Mrs. Clinton (yes, Hillary), their daughter Chelsea, and now Mrs. Obama and their daughters are being slandered and demeaned, because their husbands won the presidency in fair and open elections. If you ever read "liberal" publications such as Mother Jones and the New Republic, or foreign newspapers, you will find all of this is old news. But a lot of people seem to have forgotten or be unaware.
Report This
By: DJ on 12/01/2010 10:34AM
Some people can't get over Camelot, these people are dead, let them die and rest in peace. Mrs. Obama, is doing her own thing, keep up the good work.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Michele on 12/02/2010 6:31PM
Some people seem to forget that there was a whole lot of screwing around going on in the White House when JFK was President. Marilyn Monroe and many more. Let's get real. Is that what we want. Oh, yeah, some of the other people might because it would be the so called "typical Black Man." Not this time.
Report This
By: sharkchops on 12/04/2010 10:02AM
It hasn't been "Camelot" since the Kennedy administration so why does it have to be that way now. People are just made cuz they can't get any dirt on Shelly. She's an all true woman. Get over it. Go pick on Palin. She's got plenty of dirt for you to scrape from under your fingernails.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: ctm on 12/01/2010 6:41PM
Do you think the First Lady gives a hoot!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Gigi Jones on 12/01/2010 11:26PM
Just wondering: Are these complainers from the "Real Housewives of DC"? LOL!
If they supported Mrs. Obama, and had some respect for what she is trying to do, maybe they'd be invited to the White House more. Or maybe if they had some business, Mrs. Obama would be interested in them. If they are the "ladies who lunch" and do charity events just to show off how fabulous their outfits are, then no, Mrs. Obama probably isn't interested in those kind of "girls". Mrs. Obama is a woman, doing woman's work. If they want to get on her good side, they should offer a hand, not their snide commentary. The best way to make a friend is to be a friend.
Reply to this Comment | Report This