TIGTA is recommending that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) step up its monitoring of prisoners' tax filings in an effort to prevent fraudulent returns and fraudulent refunds. The IRS is already combating such fraud, which officials say has recently exploded. According to a recently-released audit report from TIGTA, the IRS identified 249,185 fraudulent tax returns and prevented the issuance of $1.48 billion in fraudulent refunds during the 2010 tax-filing season. That represented a whopping 50% increase over the number of fraudulent tax returns identified during the 2009 filing season, the report found.
However, the report also concluded that the tax returns of individuals deemed "most likely" to engage in fraud are seldom screened by the IRS. TIGTA's analysis found that the majority of tax returns the IRS identifies as being filed by prisoners are not being screened to assess their fraud potential.Specifically, TIGTA says that 253,929, or 88%, of the 287,918 returns filed by prisoners as of March 24, 2010 were not selected for screening. Of those, 48,887 who claimed refunds totaling more than $130 million had no wage information reported to the IRS by employers. As a result, TIGTA wants the IRS to take its screening efforts to the next level – going after prisoners who may be hitting up the government for fraudulent tax refund checks.
TIGTA says that with better access to wage and withholding information, the IRS could catch and prevent more tax fraud. "While the IRS is identifying larger numbers of fraudulent returns, improvements must be made to its screening processes to ensure that returns filed by prisoners get adequate scrutiny," said J. Russell George, the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration. "Unscrupulous individuals, including prisoners, continue to submit tax returns with false income documents to the IRS for the sole purpose of receiving a fraudulent refund," he added.
Under current law, the IRS has limited access to wage information submitted by federal agencies and state workforce agencies to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Only individuals claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit have their wage information submitted to the IRS. In addition, the IRS could benefit from expediting the use of wage and withholding information it receives from the Social Security Administration (SSA), the TIGTA report suggested.
TIGTA made several recommendations to the IRS:
-seeking increased access to HHS data, which would be done via legislative changes
-verifying whether the 48,887 tax returns with tax refunds that were filed by prisoners with no reported wages were fraudulent
-identifying revisions that could be made data systems to better identify fraudulent tax returns filed by prisoners
-expediting the use of Social Security Administration data
Interestingly, the IRS isn't fully on board with TIGTA's recommendations. While it agreed with most of TIGTA's suggestions, the IRS disagreed with the amount of potential savings from expanded and expedited access to SSA data and improving verification of prisoner tax returns. So officials are trying to decide the best, most cost-effective ways to handle those areas.
This isn't the first-time that TIGTA has recommended a crackdown of prisoner tax returns. Five years ago, based on a September 2005 audit, TIGTA also produced a report concluding that the the Internal Revenue Service needs to do more to stop the millions of dollars in fraudulent refunds paid to prisoners.
Either way, the hand-writing is on the wall and the message is clear: If you're locked up, don't try filing a bogus income tax return. It just might cost you even more time in the slammer.
Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, an award-winning financial news journalist and former Wall Street Journal reporter for CNBC, has been featured in the Washington Post, USA Today, and the New York Times, as well as magazines ranging from Essence and Redbook to Black Enterprise and Smart Money. Check out her New York Times best seller 'Zero Debt: The Ultimate Guide to Financial Freedom.'

Comments: (25)
Add a comment
By: Warren D on 12/07/2010 7:28PM
First of all, why, and how are prisoners filing tax returns warranting refunds!? And how stupid is this whack agency to not know these people are in f**king prison?! So cons and deviants can (and do) get a refund - but thousands of honest, working people out here can't ?!! Are you shi**ing me !!???
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: MAC on 12/08/2010 2:03PM
I agree Warren, how in the hell do prisoners doing time (not making enough to warrant filing income taxes) able to file and get refunds?
Report This
By: RAY on 12/08/2010 5:06PM
Iy's called residuals. ELVIS PRESLEY'S estate and MICHAEL JACKON'S estate are two of the largest money makers in the US. they're not going to put those two in jail, but the IRS will tax the estates in they're names.
Report This
By: cathylintsw on 12/08/2010 9:13PM
Ever wonder why or even know why the US went 76 years without an income tax? Ward Dean MD, former Delta Force surgeon, is doing seven years in Florida for refusing to pay IRS taxes.. I know we women have lots of standards to pick up a man, and there's one website that can almost meet all our different demands:
( B-l-a-c-k-w-h-i-t-e-C-u-p-i-d . C-o-m ) my sisiter told me this; it worked for her, it worked for me; and i'm sure it's gonna work for u, buddy!!
Report This
By: Cyberzooid on 12/08/2010 5:39AM
Ever wonder why or even know why the US went 76 years without an income tax? Ward Dean MD, former Delta Force surgeon, is doing seven years in Florida for refusing to pay IRS taxes. I see a direct connection between the aristocracy which runs the US in cloistered privacy, puppet presidents, media sideshow magazines, and white phosphorus burns on children in Palastine, Afganistan, Iraq. The black community has real leaders. Stand up! Push away the potluck potatoes. Only within the last 12 years have the KKK etc types come to realize how correct Malcom X was in stating the 14th amendment gave corporations the unseen qualities (personhood) of the old testament God. The 13th amendment was signed into law by Lincoln to preserve slavery. Howard Zinn's history book "People's History" and themoneymasters.com documentary will give you the tool to gently pick apart the "BIG LIE" and speak with credibility.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Mitchell Fletcher on 12/08/2010 5:13PM
Please, finish the lesson
Report This
By: Gail on 12/08/2010 8:39AM
I saw the Larry King Live interview with Wesley Snipes, his lawyer and Judge Joe Brown. It was very interesting. The story/defense is crazy, BUT BELIEVABLE!!!!!!...Mr. Snipes is being "Black Railroaded". He needs our prayers!!!......LORD PLEASE HELP HIM!!!!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: bova39r@aol.com on 12/08/2010 4:47PM
Regarding the Wesley Snipes tax issue, I think it's a travesty. Isn't the primary goal of the IRS collecting taxes. If a billionaire, millionaire, or thousandaire is capable of paying their taxes and ultimately adheres to the IRS' demands then they should be allowed to pay the debt without serving time. I can recall 5yrs ago Barbara Streisand owed the IRS 15,000,000.00 in unpaid taxes and she consistently prolonged payment. Yet she never received any threats of imprisonment or major punishment. As it stands she still hasn't paid off the debt.
So please tell me how and why our society will benefit from incarcerating someone who trusted his lethargic, irresponsible, criminal minded lawyers to handle his affairs. Wesley Snipes was and is well within his rights to challenge the supposition of the Federal Governments Constitutional Laws that protect insurance companies, investment firms, banks, and mortgage companies. This is a witch hunt plain and simple, if numerous judges and lawyers are mentioning the gross negligence and indiscretions of the prosecutor then Snipes case should be appealed.
Report This
By: Jewel on 12/08/2010 6:12PM
After hearing what Judge Joe Brown had to say on his behalf on the Larry King Show, I think Mr. Snipes may indeed be a target of someone or some persons who do not like him for whatever reason.
Report This
By: ALVIS JENKINS on 12/18/2010 8:05PM
Wesley Snipes had a lawyer that got his degree from WalMart. Anyone that will make the effort to do some research will find that no one is made laible for payment of income taxes. Therefore income tax evasion is nonexistant. Also know this, lawyers are loyal to the court before their client. Wesley Snipes did not have due process. Nowhere in the Internal Revenue Code is there a requirement for anyone to file a 1040 form. The income tax is paid on a voluntary basis by federal employees only. Federal tax liens and levies do not apply to subtitle "A" taxes (Income taxes), only apply to ATF taxes of subtitle "E" of Title 26. Nowhere in Title 26 is there a requirement for anyone to file a return for any tax that they are not liable for. Private sector citizens not engaged in a "trade or business" with the United States have no obligation to pay the federal income tax. It is a known fact that the DOJ and IRS employees in prosecutions are incarcerating innocent citizens of the private sector by denying them of due process in their defense. Maybe Mr Snipes will learn a little more after serving the false imprisonment and know the law and not hire just any lawyer because as it stands now, lawyers are on the endangered list.
Report This