With black unemployment holding at double digits, the catastrophic cut off of capital to black-owned businesses is just one more disturbing trend in what is shaping up to be the Great Black Depression.
A recent study found that in some parts of the country banks decreased lending to black-owned businesses by over 80 percent. And that's not just loans to get businesses off the ground, but also the financing needed by black businesses to continue operating and make payroll.
In light of criticisms that previous attempts at spurring small business lending actually tied small businesses and lenders in knots of red tape while increasing costs, the Small Business Administration recently introduced two new loan initiatives: Small Loan Advantage and Community Advantage. Although these programs will not be available until March 2011, the SBA promises that they will target lending in under-served communities by promoting small dollar loans, providing higher loan guarantees to banks and streamlining the approval process.
I spoke with Marie Johns, Deputy Administrator of the U.S. Small Business Administration to find out if these two new programs would benefit the African American community. Here is her perspective.
Gina: Conventional wisdom is that lenders aren't lending -- so how do we know that lenders are going to be more inclined to lend under this program than they were under previous programs?
Deputy Administrator Marie Johns: Through the Recovery Act and the Small Business Jobs Act we were able to increase our lending even when traditional small business lending was pretty stagnant, but we know that with these new programs, we're going to have even more opportunities to help small businesses. They reduce paperwork for the lenders. They offer the highest guarantee that we offer -- 85% on loans under $150,000 and 75% on loans higher than that. The initiatives are pegged at the smaller dollar loans, $250,000 or less, which is a part of the small business lending market that has generally been tough to address.
Gina: According to a a recent study by the California Reinvestment Coalition, small business lending for African Americans plummeted 81 percent for African American owned businesses between 2007 and 2009. How do these new programs address a decline being attributed to African Americans having less collateral and more limited credit histories?
Deputy Administrator Johns: This clearly is an issue that is very important to me and its very important to the Agency and led us to think about how we could have a better response to these critical capital needs for businesses, particularly for African American businesses and other businesses in communities of color. SBA loans are three to five times more likely to go to a woman-owned or a minority-owned small business. But we've seen lending tighten up across the board particularly in traditionally under-served communities. We know that those communities have been disproportionately hard hit by the recession. As a result of that, the overall share of SBA loans going to small businesses and entrepreneurs in under-served communities has dropped over the past two years. That's why we wanted to add these two new loan initiatives into our tool kit.
What we were hearing from lending partners is that some of our SBA paperwork was burdensome and too complicated. We developed the Small Loan Advantage program with the specific focus on making sure it was as streamlined as possible. Basically, it's a two page form so that they can quickly make loans available to small businesses who qualify. That's one response to the challenge that you raised.
In addition, we thought that it was very important to bring into SBA 's network of lending partners a new category -- what we refer to as "mission lenders." When you talk about the notion of African Americans having issues related to collateral or credit history, the benefit of the mission lenders who we'll be working with to deliver the Community Advantage program, is that these lenders are often community development financial institutions, SBA approved microlenders, or certified development companies and financial institutions who have tremendous experience in working in underserved markets. In addition to providing loans, they also provide very robust technical assistance. In additional to the capital these lenders are providing the counseling that often is the critical ingredient for businesses to ensure their success. These lenders will be partners for the first time in 7A loan program. We're excited about what we think is going be a tremendous improvement in our efforts to reach businesses in underserved areas.
Gina: What steps should a small business take if they are interested in obtaining a loan under one of these new programs?
Deputy Administrator Johns: Our new website allows a small business person to log on SBA.gov and the website will lead you to one of our 68 district offices . You can go into one of our 68 offices and you can talk to someone and they can tell you what your next steps should be.
Gina: Black people got hammered economically in 2010. Do you have any predictions for how things might change or what role the SBA will play in 2011?
Deputy Administrator Johns: I'm not good at the crystal ball exercise. What I can commit to you is that we're going to work as hard as we possibly can. We come in every day on fire to figure out what we can to do to support small business growth and development so that those small businesses can create the jobs that the economy must have. We talk bout the critical role that small businesses play -- they are the engines for our economy's growth. To the extent that we can create tools for small businesses to start, grow and create jobs, that helps the entire economy to grow stronger. What I can predict is that we will continue to have a team at the SBA that comes in every day to figure how to do what we do better and serve small businesses more effectively.
Deputy Administrator Johns also wanted emphasize that the Small Business Administration offers a number of services to small businesses in addition to their loan programs including small business counseling, assistance with becoming a government contractor, and disaster assistance. You can find our more by going to SBA.gov.
Gina McCauley is the CEO of the Blogging While Brown Conferenceand the blogsMichelle Obama Watch and What About Our Daughters. She is currently completing her first book, 'Michelle Obama Watch.'


Comments: (5)
Add a comment
By: Jacque on 12/30/2010 2:54PM
These bastards didn't discriminate when it came to taking taxpayers dollars, did they?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: jsloroll on 1/02/2011 5:04AM
You should be ashamed of stereotyping all black people. There are many of us who are responsible and who are not as you say, " in jail or call our women out of their names." If you are black, which I don't believe you are, then you should put yourself in the same category. BTW, we do not do more drugs than other races. Do your research before you make assumptions.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: rhonda on 12/31/2010 12:52PM
Thank you "jsloroll" for saying what needed to be said. More of us are responsible and want the best for our families like everyone else. But of course the media doesn't report that.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: The Cynic on 12/31/2010 5:20PM
What have Black Americans done to show we deserve more credit than others? Fill the jails? Do more drugs than any other group? Embrace "music" that celebrates our women as "ho's?"
You honestly believe that the people within this segment of the Black community are the ones looking for loans to start businesses and pay their employees? Please
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: SMalone on 3/30/2011 9:22AM
Perhaps in your next interview with Marie Johns you can ask her these facts...
SBA Community Express
After Its Demise, What Happens To African American Lending?
Let’s take a look at SBA’s Strategic Plan Under the current Administration:
Section 1.6:
1.6. Strengthen outreach to underserved communities with high unemployment and high levels of poverty and underserved populations, including ethnic minorities, women, and veterans.
Inside The Numbers: SBA Community Express is a widely popular unsecured loan program with competitive rates, quick funding, and minimal paperwork—geared especially for smaller business ventures and especially women and minorities. The average size loan is $10,000. Since SBA Capped Community Express (“CX”) and changed the Program, making it more difficult for lenders to participate, SBA loan volume for African Americans has gone from 10% to a low of 2%.
CX lenders (top 3) accounted for 3,688 loans to African Americans from 2008-2011. This number accounted for 60% of the overall 6,200 loans made to African Americans. Superior Financial Group funded 2,018 loans to African Americans during 2008-2011, which was more than JP Morgan Chase, Wells Fargo, Compass Bank, U.S. Bank, Bank Of America and Capital One……………………………………COMBINED!
To meet SBA’s Mission and Strategic Plan they cancelled CX. And replaced it with a new pilot program called Small Loan Advantage.
This program mirrors SBA “Rural Advantage”. So how is Rural Advantage performing?
2010…………..funded 1,047 total loans. The average size was $156,666 and required collateral. It only produced 14 loans under 50K unsecured from 2008-2011. It clearly will not meet the needs of the underserved, because it will require collateral with equity that no longer exists in low to moderate income areas.
In the recent House Small Business Committee hearings, the committee is recommending no new SBA lending programs. Thus, if the new programs Small Loan Advantage and Community Advantage are both canceled due to the budget cuts then small minority and women owned business will be without any programs. Would it not make sense to keep a program which has proved to work for 10 years as a pilot program and have an impact on the SBA budget of .012%? As stated in the hearings, the new programs SBA has brought forward during the last two years have not increased jobs at all.
In fact, the largest increase in budget request is from SBA it is $132 million. “To account for higher than estimated historical default rates in part due to loans made based on inflated collateral such as real estate!” This is over and above the $3.8 billion shortfall in this year’s SBA budget to cover once again the devalue in real estate from loans made prior to the collapse.
The Last and Final Point: SBA has a strategic goal to reach underserved businesses. However, they don’t have any programs that are permanent, so lenders can build an infrastructure around. CX ran successfully for 10 years as a pilot and still SBA did not make the program permanent. How can we as lenders reach the underserved when there are no program incentives to do so? Further, statistically the underserved markets have a higher loss ratio than others, yet SBA’s Lender oversight expects the portfolios to perform the same. When they don’t, the lender is crucified!
Conclusion: SBA has made it clear through their actions they do not want to lend to underserved markets. These proclamations are but “window dressing” with no follow through or interest in delivering products to those most in need. The pilot program that ran for 10 years has been terminated? African American lending is lower today than under the Bush Years! This inexcusable failing must be rectified so these communities may again prosper and add taxes, purchase good and services, hire employees, and reverse our Nation’s economic downturn.
Reply to this Comment | Report This