
Most of us at BlackVoices are familiar with the case of Kelley Williams-Bolar, the Ohio mother of two who was sent to jail for sending her children to the "wrong" school district. Williams-Bolar was sentenced to 10 days in jail, three years probation and community service for using her father's address to avoid sending her kids to the school she considered to be dangerous and inadequate. At AOL BlackVoices, we were one of the first to hit the issue nationally, and fortunately, other media outlets are starting to take notice.
In addition to being sent to jail, Williams-Bolar and her father are being charged with fourth-degree grand theft of school services. As a consequence of her conviction, Williams-Bolar will never be allowed to teach in the state of Ohio, which is the profession she was pursing. The judge also made it clear that she was sending Williams-Bolar to jail as an example for other parents thinking about doing the same thing.
The case sparked a firestorm of national controversy and conversation about educational inequality and the notion that a mother had to break the law in order to give her daughters access to a quality education. Millions of parents expressed support for Williams-Bolar, for they too could recall their own parents making the same sacrifices for them. There have been Facebook groups created to support Williams-Bolar and change.org has created a petition on her behalf to have her record expunged. The petition drew nearly 20,000 signatures over a three-day period and is growing by the second.
Yesterday, I got a call from CNN's 'AC360,' and it appears that we will get the chance to talk about the Williams-Bolar case on the show tonight. This is in addition to other media outlets from as far as Japan that have called me about the matter. I was happy to see the national media pick up this story because it is far bigger than one person. It is really about addressing the fundamental human rights violations that lead to a two-tiered racialized reality in America when it comes to our economic, educational and criminal justice systems.
Black family wealth being significantly lower than that of white families (due to slavery and Jim Crow) reminds us that had Williams-Bolar been a wealthy woman from the suburbs, it is highly unlikely that she would have been used as an example by the court. I am compelled to believe that the prosecutor would have used his discretion to keep this incident from permanently staining her record and would not have forced this law-abiding mother to endure the dehumanization of walking around in a dirty jailhouse jump suit for nearly two weeks.
Most white Americans don't have to break the law to get their children access to a good education. But millions of Americans, disproportionately those of color, are being forced to jump the legal fence to sneak their kids into quality academic programs. Having a decent, safe venue of education should be a fundamental American right, not something we have to break the law to receive. While it might have been illegal for Williams-Bolar to fight for her kids to get into a good school, we must remember that it was also once illegal for slaves to learn how to read. My point is that legality is not always the same as morality, so the argument that she's wrong because she broke the law is simply invalid.
This case is clearly about more than just one person. I am not here to vouch for Williams-Bolar or her family, for I am just getting to know them personally and we should be careful to keep our minds focused on the broader issues at hand (in case the powers-that-be attempt to slander Kelley to divert the national media attention). It is about thoroughly examining the structure of our legal, educational and economic systems in America. President Barack Obama, more than a year and a half ago, chose to use the Henry Louis Gates case as an opportunity to argue in favor of an awkward conversation on race that never happened. The problem is that an inconvenience being thrust on one of President Obama's Harvard cronies was hardly the venue for the president to talk about what happens to the common black man or woman in America. But if the president or anyone in Washington wants a real opportunity to talk seriously about racial inequality in America, the Williams-Bolar situation is a textbook case of what is racially wrong with our society. I hope that the Congressional Black Caucus, the NAACP, the National Action Network and other major organizations get involved in this case. It is an opportunity to help millions of people.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce's commentary delivered to your e-mail, please click here. 
Comments: (88)
Add a comment
By: jean on 1/27/2011 11:14AM
The more things change, the more they stay the same. Its' truly unfair how your zip code or your address defines the type of education you are to receive. As minorities you have been marked and will be scarred for the rest of your life if, you don't find a way to get your children a better education in a good and safe location. I would do it in a heart-beat all over again to give my children a leg up. Being that I did so, All of my children were honor roll students and I would not change a thing.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: raven on 1/27/2011 12:16PM
Repeat offenders should get stiffer sentences, don't you agree?
Report This
By: Watcher Watchmen on 1/27/2011 2:53PM
@ raven on 1/27/2011 12:16PM
**********************************************
Repeat offenders should get stiffer sentences, don't you agree?
**********************************************
Yes this is agreed!
As long as the “Visible Concentrations of Melanin” of one’s skin color, does not become the "Deciding Factor" as to whether there's a conviction, (if anything at all), for the repeat offense, yet along the “degree of punishment(s)” for the first offense.
Until this ever changes, the one-liners those of your ilk are known to (commonly) bottom-out on, are not only hypocritical, (on your part), but also unwittingly stated with blind ignorance.
Kelley Williams Bolar is incriminated for seeking to improve her children’s chances of a better education at a school known for providing such, by comparison to a local school systemically designed for the lesser.
If all things preceded/proceeded on leveled playing fields to begin with, her actions wouldn’t likely have been so considered.
Besides, at least she thought enough of her children to rise in their best interests for good reasons, which in itself, is a far cry from the kinds of black parenting those of your ilk are known to finger-out and scoff at.
Another approach to Kelley Williams Bolar's actions should be the results of her child’s learning improvements by comparison at the better school over the local school, otherwise known to have lesser resources.
Given how long they’ve attended the school having comparatively more advanced resources, did their grades/learning curve improve?
The results should also be included behind the motive(s) of Kelley Williams Bolar's judgment(s).
And finally, do you believe she’s the first who have ever done this statewide, in as much as being the first of her ethnicity?
-Yet along to have received the same punishment?
Report This
By: Relevance? on 1/27/2011 3:09PM
@Watcher Watchman:
If you research this story You will find that many attempts were made to resolve the issue. Ms Bolar refused to cooperate. However, there were many other families that got caught and cooperated with the school district. Its such ashame that a complete picture is not presented. Ms Bolar was NOT singled out by any person or group.
Report This
By: Chantilly Patiño on 1/27/2011 3:52PM
Jean, thank you for speaking up for this woman. That fact that this mother even had to consider such a choice is the most disgusting detail in this case. No mother should have to choose between quality education and safe neighborhoods vs. limited education and dangerous neighborhoods. The color line and poverty line are clearly evident in America!
http://biculturalmom.blogspot.com/
Report This
By: jeromequigley on 1/27/2011 5:12PM
@Watcher Watchmen: and it was not simply she was seeking a better education. Others have said that the grandfather paid taxes in that area why does that not count?? Well because he had falsely tried to declare his home as a nursing home and during that time was exempt from paying taxes(do as I do not as I say is the lesson kids really learn)! So that is why he is facing seperate charges of the same caliper. Yet the Judge would not allow that to be entered because she did not want it to cause a unfair decision on Ms Williams-Bolar...What a Evil Judge this woman is!!(NOT!). And the fact that at the same time she claimed to live with her father to avoid paying the tuition into the school( that other parents, including black parents paid). Yet at the same time the apartment she supposedly did not live in, was being subsidized(paid for) by the county! And the school her girls were going to was not some reg. public school which so many get wrong. It did NOT HAVE OPEN ENROLLMENT!! But with her cheating the system, the parents that pays taxes or pays tuition have to pay more when peepz cheat the system, IS THAT FAIR TO THEM???? IF the school disctrict she was in was sooo bad she could of 1)moved or 2)did some thing about it!!! So many say "oh she had to do it to get her kids a better education and she would of done anything for them". OK then why did she not start a parent group in her district? one that worked hand in hand with the school, to do what was needed to make the school a better school for ALL THE KIDS?? It is why so many say they did it to get to a better(and they say "white") school. Well that is the problem, to many parents only worried about themselves and not the entire community. If these parents are willing to do ANYTHING then they should fight to make their neighborhoods and schools better!! Make it so parents in other area's want to try and get into their schools. But no, they want the easy and selfish route of "I'll help my kids and the heck with the rest of you". Think long and hard about that!!!! Finally, other than the fact she is black what racial over-tone is there in this case??? And no bringing up the past or anything like that..I AM TALKING HERE AND NOW, THIS CASE BASED ON THE FACTS...WHAT IS RACIAL ABOUT IT OTHER THAN SHE IS BLACK???? NOTHING AT ALL...SO WAS THE SCHOOL SUPPOSED TO NOT ASK FOR WHAT IS DUE TO THEM BECAUSE SHE IS BLACK??? I hope you consider some of what I have said and reflect honestly about it. I would truely like to hear your opinion(no BS, I am interested in a thinking persons perspective)! And please got to OHIO.COM and read all the related articles on this to get the entire picture. Then instead of her view, try the other parents view who work hard to afford that school and how many had to pull their kids because the tuition was raised to high one year, and why did it go up...because of peepz cheating the system!!
Report This
By: Watcher Watchmen on 1/28/2011 4:32AM
@ Relevance?
Per comment on 1/27/2011 3:09PM
@ jeromequigley
Per comment on 1/27/2011 5:12PM
Read both of your responses to ours and although your point was well taken, you were both offbeat to the point of ours.
Neither of what either of you had stated, has correctly countered ours.
But rather was a response to your own tailored versions of what you two had assumed (misinterpreted) what you’ve read from our post, spent it accordingly and then argued upon “THAT”
We’re somewhat surprised at you, @ Relevance, to have insultingly assumed that we’ve not read the whole story (available at just a click away), before our getting involved (posting) in this forum.
According to “OUR” post, the primary point of our response was to what was broadly implied against Kelley Williams Bolar in the comment made by @ raven on 1/27/2011 12:16PM.
(Available to be reviewed at will)
We’ve then elaborated on the fundamentals of Kelley Williams Bolar’s choices, as we understand quite well of those in her situation, which are a lot bigger than those in her shoes.
Although we’ve not condoned her “Method”, we do realize the motive and have also put forth the question of whether her children benefited from the results of attending a better school. Ironically, in lieu of all that had occurred, this had not popped up in the midst.
**Also, we now add, with her being several credits away from her teaching degree, she was just as well working her away “OFF the system” to support her own.
(Something most whites argue that blacks in her situation don’t or “wont” do!)
Her higher salary would have paid for any preceding damages.
We believe (however arguable), that if she was not “herself”, her being so close to her teaching degree wouldn’t have been threatened but rather allowed (worked around) with the understanding that upon her official employment, (salary increase) she’d be on a payment plan and like may other daily cases in court that are far worse than hers, the “public” wouldn’t know about it, especially at this magnitude.
(We know the tricks of the law! Especially in favor of white college youths who’s crimes are sometimes made lesser if not expunged, as to not effect their college careers, as so “heard stated” from judges during their arraignments. Feel free to observe the Night and Day differences of convictions between Blacks and Whites for the same crime committed, which also contribute to their comparative differences filling the prisons. It still exists! Pick a Courtroom (or cop) and “Observe” for yourselves!)
But as for the “Whole Story”, it can be spent in whatever way that suits the reader.
(One would read and hone in on everything that likely supports what one argues.)
Our comment was aimed at the fundamentals and has also terminated with the following;
*Do you believe she’s the first who have ever done this statewide, in as much as being the first of her ethnicity?
*-Yet along to have received the same punishment?
Furthermore, several (years worth of) families were realized for having done the same but according to the media trends, it’s unlikely they were all black families, else the media would have irresistibly made it their point to “ADVERTISE” this, by now.
You can almost always know when whites commit crimes, Race is often not mentioned(of suspect in custody), the Crime report is often sweetened up, insanity (medication) often becomes the blame, or its immediately followed by something a black person did as a balance and more, as such has been the “observed” trends of the NEWS media’s reporting schemes.
(What’s not said, can speak as well as what’s said.)
Report This
By: Blackwoman4justice on 1/28/2011 12:24PM
This is a national issue. Harvard University has conducted a study regarding the criminality of blacks and education prior to the standing President's election. The ACLU has made mention of it and it can be seen on it's website but action needs to take place. It's called "The School to Prison Pipeline". Look it up. A March needs to occur on Washington from MLK memorial to the White House for compensation and equal access for African American children who have been cheated within the last 30 years by their own schools or giving the $11,000 tax money expended each year on children to parents themselves to educate their own children instead of a school district. Some school districts have smart boards in EVERY classroom! The black school districts and low income school districts do not. If one school district has it, all of them should. Many predominantly low income and black areas have chalk boards still instead. If I had $11,000 per child that my family has ALWAYS paid into this system to educate my child, I wouldn't want to put my child in the best white school because of the psychological treatement of our children in their environment. I'm sure I could do it better and in love and protection. The contribution in this country has never been equal because too many black people still work for free which is part of our constitution today. It was amended that one cannot be a slave unless incarcerated. Read the constitution. I have watched the passive aggressive picking white school districts do when low income blacks move into their district legitmately like. When black people are sent to jail, the system makes money off of them. It appears that is not an accident. A black child is worth $50,000 a year to the system in jail. For anyone purporting blacks don't contribute, between being a slave, a sharecropper, an inmate, blackballed in the workplace or business market..we have. What is going on? This attempt has happened to me personally and several black single mothers I know nationwide. We are not criminals. We are mothers who care. The language is always the same, "We have to maintain the safety of our school and students"..."We have to protect the best interest of the child"... So as to say Black women are incapable. The fact is, black women for years raised white children and the country was less corrupt when that was the way things went. That's not a pervailing topic in our history books however. The schools also have an issue with not protecting black people's privacy rights. There should be a tracking system to find out who is accessing personal data given to the school each time it is references with a passcode the parent can look up. We also need to know when our information is sent out to other sources because that allows disparity to continue. This case exposes a long overdue topic to be resolved not merely discussed. We need to March for compensation on Washington. We will never get equal access if we rely on this failing, biased system.
Report This
By: jeromequigley on 1/27/2011 11:16AM
Thank-you Dr W for continually burying yourself further on this issue! When ALL THE FACTS COME OUT YOU WILL BE EATING YOUR JIM "CROW" . Let the true facts come to light!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: stare k on 1/27/2011 4:05PM
TO Jeromequigley What about TOM DELAY
WHAT ABOUT TOM DELAY THE EX HOUSE SPEAKER .HE GO A SLAP ON THE WRIST,SLAP ON THE WRIST .THAT ALL YES HE'S WHITE .
Report This