
Many black athletes take what some consider to be the ultimate gamble: trading in nearly all of their educational opportunities in exchange for a lottery ticket that only goes to one man out of a thousand. It's not a wise trade, to be sure. It is also part of the skewed reality of little black boys influenced by media that is obsessed with black male athletic prowess. Images of Carmelo Anthony tattooed from head-to-toe, standing next to Amare Stoudemire after being traded to the New York Knicks serve as fuel to the fire of hoop dreams that typically end up turning into nightmares. Hip-hop culture, mixed with mass marketing of African American athletes, has created a community where every black boy wants to dribble a basketball, throw a football, or bust rhymes for a living.
As many of us already know, most of these basketball fantasies never come to life. Far too many of these men end their athletic careers between the ages of 17 and 24 (depending on when they finally realize they aren't good enough for the next level), and end up in the ranks of thousands of uneducated African American males who make up the highest unemployment rate of any race/gender group in the entire United States. They may also become valuable commodities for the prison industrial complex, where black men are as common as the metal bars that keep them encased in the only place where the Constitution actually allows slavery to exist.
One of the primary beneficiaries of the "Great Black Male Athletic Illusion" is the NCAA. After being given exemptions from American anti-trust law which allow them to control the labor rights of athletes, the NCAA earns over a billion dollars every year from the athletic labor of college athletes in revenue-generating sports, the vast majority of whom are African American males. This year, the NCAA is set to earn $610 million from the licensing fees coming from ad revenue generated by March Madness alone. Depending on the year, March Madness ad revenue can easily exceed money earned from the entire post-season of every other major professional sport. It is regularly ranked in the top three, and ad spots for the NCAA championship game cost over one-third the price of an ad for the Super Bowl.
Between 2000 and 2009, the NCAA earned over $4.5 billion in ad revenue from March Madness. Additionally, the ad income for CBS online content from March Madness has surpassed the $30 million dollar mark. If the players from March Madness and their families were allowed to evenly split the money being earned from advertising revenue by itself, they would walk away with an average of $790,000 per player, with the top players earning as much as $10 million, just for this one tournament. This does not include millions earned during the regular season, as well as revenue earned from concessions, merchandising, video games, and the like.
The $790,000 in average economic contribution to the ad revenue pool for March Madness would be more than 15 - 20 times greater than the cost of attending even the most expensive universities in America. Therefore, the argument that players are getting a fair trade by receiving a college scholarship is beyond the bounds of silly. Making matters worse, as a college professor for the last 17 years, I can tell you that the professional athletic schedules of college athletes in revenue generating sports makes it extremely difficult for these students to go to class or be a normal part of the campus environment. If education were a top priority, then students would not be asked to miss class regularly to play nationally-televised games on ESPN.
The multi-billion dollar class action lawsuit being filed against the NCAA by Oscar Robinson, Ed O'Bannon and many other former athletes is a great start to making things right with the NCAA. For years, the NCAA has been allowed to use athlete images for their own benefit, with a large number of NCAA commentators, coaches and administrators making themselves into millionaires. Unfortunately, American racism shows it's ugly face in the NCAA's segregated design: Most of the individuals being paid millions are white, while those earning the money on the court are black. Additionally, many of the black athletes come from homes that are impoverished, and it's interesting that the nation finds it scandalous when these multi-million dollar commodities are found to have even gotten a tiny taste of the wealth they are generating for other people. It's as if we as a country have decided that these men don't deserve to have equal rights.
There was a time when laws were designed to keep African Americans from experiencing the financial rewards from their labor. Today, similar laws are in place with a more subtle and indirect racial impact. It should probably be considered that part of the reason that the American public doesn't care about college athletes being unpaid is because they see a bunch of black guys who should be happy to get the little they are receiving. The same argument can be used to justify the treatment of a five-year old kid in a Chinese sweatshop. After all, the five-year old doesn't have to work for a dollar a day, he can go do something else. But at some point in American history, we decided that workers should have the right to demand fair wages, and that we are not a Communist society. But it seems that our American values are readily compromised when it comes to maintaining our addiction to racial oppression, and the NCAA seems happy to lead the way.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and the Athlete Liberation and Academic Reform Movement (ALARM). To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. To follow Dr. Boyce on Facebook, please click here. 
Comments: (16)
Add a comment
By: jamarcus on 2/23/2011 5:58AM
I am looking forward to March Madness starting; this is the only basketball I watch all year.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Charlie on 2/23/2011 3:07PM
Let all atheletes enter college with only their academic achievements and SAT/ACT scores. This would eliminate a lot of the racism you are complaining about and help our students focus on their real future.
I agree with you, let the NFL and NBA set up their own minor league systems. They could help teach the 70% of NFL players that file bankruptcy 2 years after retirement. Then the 90% or higher of these college athletes that will never go pro can sit at home without a chnce of getting a college education. The playground doesnt pay much and the benefits suck.
The NBA has lost viewership because nobody wants to see these overpaid babies play hard for 1/4.
The same will happen with the NCAA when you pay players, the game will go into the dumpster.
We never hear white writers complain about being paid from the NCAA for players?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: jeromequigley on 2/23/2011 5:38PM
Wow, some one wiped out about 30 post on this blog!!! I know who normally keeps an eye on it and I am sure that person would not do some thing like a Mass deletion. But some one either hit a wrong switch or REALLY DID NOT WANT PEEPZ TO READ OPINIONS THAT ARE DIFFERENT FROM DR W!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: A Gentleman and a Scallop on 2/23/2011 9:03PM
Another idiotic rant from someone who proves that a PhD is no vaccine against rascism and an abject
persecution complex. Do you really think that access to a totally funded education worth upwards of $100,000 is insufficient compensation for engaging in an activity millions of kids do simply for the pure joy of it? I think the student occupying the seat next to them would strenuously disagree. If they choose to squander the opportunity to secure a valuable, free-of-charge degree then it's their own fault. The chance to make the NBA is infinitessimal and they should have the common sense and realistic expectation to recognize that. The goose is laying a golden egg for collegians based on how high they can jump and fast they can run - academics don't even play a roll in their entrance credentials - and they should be appreciative of an open bar where so many others have to pay cash.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: A Gentleman and a Scallop on 2/23/2011 10:36PM
I misspelled "racism." My passionate response caused my fingers to misfire...
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Buffalo Soldier on 2/24/2011 7:23AM
Yeah, you mis-guided scallop it would appear that your " passionate response " clouded your judgement as well. ( Or were your eyes blinded by racism ? )
You attempted to malign Dr. Watkins and dismiss his position as that of one with what you cleverly termed an " abject persecution complex ". Seriously ? I'm sure Denmark Vesey and Nat Turner were spoken of in similar terms. Or Toussaint L'Overture when he whupped Napoleans's butt & kicked him out of Haiti.
My point is that you simply don't get it man !! But then, I'm sure it's just like the arguments people like you make when you butt into discussions of other ways that we endure disparities in this society. Your eyes can't see it because your skin-color & the priviledge attached thereto blinds you to it.
Again Dr. Watkins has eloquently, clearly, and simply laid out not only the problem, but suggestions of viable solutions. As opposed to merely hurling base-less accusations ( or trying to do so ), attacking the truth, and attempting to denigrate the writer on a topic you just don't understand. Yeah, " mr.scallop " you missed the point entirely, but I'm reasonably sure it wasn't your first time doing that, was it ??
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: oefrank on 2/24/2011 10:53AM
Your article was spot on. The media has an obession with the black male athlete. It's very discouraging that these black male athletes think that they are well received with 90 percent of their bodies tattooed. Nothing against tattoos but excessive tattoos make these athletes look more thuggish. You can see the results of a lack of education when the athletes playing career is over. Over half of them lose everything. They didn't take a course on financial management and they either got swindle by people they trusted, spent too much or was living beyound their means. Ask Antoine Walker and others former professional black athletes.
Report This
By: A Gentleman and a Scallop on 2/24/2011 10:58AM
Buffalo Soldier,
I'm addressing NCAA basketball, commenting on athletes dismissing the value of a free $100,000 education and you're dropping non sequiturs about Napolean, Haiti and some guy with the riotously comical monicker of "Toussaint L'Overture" (this must be legit - you just can't make up a name that
humorous). WHAT ON EARTH ARE YOU BLABBERING ABOUT??
In terms of the "privelege" ascribed to my skin color...In 1971 I had the "privelege" of being drafted, taken out of college before finishing my degree and serving involuntarily in the U.S. Army -
the "privelege" of having to work a full-time job while completing my studies in night school afterwards (10 years later than those my own age who had avoided military service)- the "privelege"
of working my tail off starting a business and paying taxes far higher than the average citizen, with no pension, paid time off or subsidized health care - and, of course, the "privelege" of funding every pathologically lazy welfare bum, illegal alien, career criminal and child born out of wedlock within the confines if this socialistic
America of ours. WHERE AND WHEN DID MY ALABASTER, NORTHERN EUROPEAN EPIDERMIS BECOME AN ASSET??
It's undeniably obvious - "Buffalo Soldier" - from
which end of the buffalo your irrelevant comments are escaping.
Report This
By: Charlie on 2/24/2011 9:13AM
Again stop giving scholarships for athelitics, make it an intramural sport in college and put the emphasis on learning.
Let all of these so called student atheletes pay their own way into whatever school will accept them.
Then let professional sports set up a minor league system. We all know that they wouldnt take advantage of 18-22 year olds.
Or they can play on the streets for the love of the game, pays is low and the benefits sucks.
Or lets do like they do for college admissions have set asides for race-12% of the population only 12% on the basketball team-thats Dr B's reasoning.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Buffalo Soldier on 2/24/2011 11:25AM
Alright, scallop so you went to school somewhere ... ( more than likely at G. I. Bill expense; my tax-dollars, dammit !! ) .... do you want a cookie ?
To engage you in some ego-driven, racist-tinged, one-upsmanship-styled pissing contest is beneath my dignity. However, I must ask you to dig yourself, man. You got a FREE education, now you criticize other men who generate more revenue for their talent than you & 10,000 like you could in 100 lifetimes ! and yet you have the grand-audacity, the rank, incredible gaul to imply that they're somehow not worthy of being compensated ??
And I'll wager what you boast about ... your business; ( for which I congratulate you, btw ) .... was in all probability, funded with start-up capital from a loan secured by, yep you guessed it MY tax-dollars again, dammit !
You feel quite comfortable utilizing all the benefits of the " socialistic America " you bemoan, but GOD forbid someone else excercise the same rights citizenship brings to them as well. You, sir are the worst kind of hypocrite. Now go back to school and learn some REAL history and you'll know more about the names I referenced in my first response to your drivle. ( You're clearly baffled by them ! )
Reply to this Comment | Report This