
A group of children pose for a photograph during a Samaritan's Feet shoe distribution on January 13, 2010 at Refugee Empowerment Program in Memphis, Tennessee.
The vote led to a heated debate over race and class, particularly since the white and far wealthier residents of Shelby County didn't appear to support the merger. David Pickler, Chair of the Shelby County school board, is vowing to fight the merger in court. Before the merger took place, Shelby County and Memphis pooled their resources and were required to educate all children within the city of Memphis and in the surrounding suburbs. Shelby County, however, had been hoping to obtain "special district" status, allowing it to close off its boundaries to keep Memphis children out of their finances.
Memphis residents approved the referendum by a wide margin, with two-thirds of Memphis citizens supporting the move. The decision to give up the charter was made by the Memphis city school board back in December to preempt plans by the Republicans in the state legislature to allow Shelby County to separate itself from the city of Memphis. After seeing the Memphis city school board make it's move, the state legislature passed a law on February 11 requiring any transition to have a planning commission and also that such transitions can only take place three years after a vote. This gives the county plenty of time to find ways to prevent the merger from happening.
Even more interesting in this game of political cat and mouse is that the state legislature also lifted a statewide ban on the creation of special districts, allowing Shelby County to gain special status. These moves may prevent the merger from ever taking place. Shelby County has also filed a federal lawsuit seeking to stop the merger altogether.
As an outside observer to all of this, I can say that I am in favor of the move by the residents of Memphis. The idea that the wealthy folks in the suburbs can create legal barriers to our children having access to a similar quality of education simply screams of segregation, elitism and blatant civil rights violations. Tennessee, being a state that has long considered black folks to be second-class citizens, appears willing to continue with the same political shenanigans that Thurgood Marshall had to deal with over 50 years ago. Legally preventing a mostly black group of citizens from having access to the schools of a mostly white county is simply a modernized version of Jim Crow. The residents of Shelby County should be ashamed of the actions of their school board leadership, for racism is written on every wall of their ridiculous behavior.
Roland Martin, a friend for whom I have tremendous respect, has expressed outrage over voter turnout. Martin mentioned recently on Twitter and the Tom Joyner Morning Show that only 17% of the residents of the city of Memphis showed up to vote in the referendum. I agree with Martin's point on this matter. I did not, of course, agree with the fact that Roland brought a pastor onto Joyner's Show (Kenneth Whalum) to oppose the merger, but didn't even acknowledge the other point of view. Additionally, Pastor Whalum was not able to provide hard facts and data to support his assertions (unlike the information I received from another pastor in the Memphis area, Stacy L. Spencer). I wasn't convinced by his arguments and after doing further research on the issue, I personally concluded that Memphis residents had no other choice but to merge with the Shelby school system.
On an issue as critical as this one, all of the residents of Memphis should have been compelled to speak up for their kids. The lack of voter participation within the city of Memphis is a sad reflection of two fundamental facts: Many African Americans don't feel that the political process has a direct impact on their lives, thus making them feel powerless. It also reflects the fact that, unfortunately, African Americans have lost our understanding of the extreme importance of education. When our kids don't get properly educated, they end up dead, unemployed, in jail or in poverty. No parent should want this for their children, so we've all got to do better.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. To follow Dr. Boyce on Facebook, please click here. 
Comments: (16)
Add a comment
By: Davis on 3/09/2011 1:11PM
Allowing barely-civilized 'hoodrats to flood the classrooms of decent schools will NOT improve the education of the 'hoodrats, it will only serve to destroy the educational environment for EVERYBODY.
What Watkins fails to mention (of course) is that the successful, hard-working BLACK families of Shelby County didn't want the merger, either.
I can't say I blame them.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Terrence on 3/09/2011 5:56PM
Really?
You can't blame them. The entire situation is bad, but the worst part of it is the SCS not wanting to take care of its responsibility because last time I check in Tennessee it is the county's responsibility to educate all children in its county. So many suburbanites have so many issues with Memphis, so I say stay out of Memphis. That means, don’t work, shop, eat, or anything else in Memphis if you don’t like Memphis. Do that and we will see how long the surrounding areas of Memphis keep up its $83.998 median household income? Let’s keep the facts straight, Shelby County needs Memphis, the two largest employers are in Memphis and one being MCS
Also, it’s not about having children from Memphis going to schools in the County. It’s about having equal funding for all students in Shelby County. And let’s not forget that the only nationally ranked school in Shelby County is White Station H.S. which is a Memphis City School. And let’s be honest about it the same dirty that happens in a MCS school happens in SCS. SCS just does a better job at covering it up.
Report This
By: Tate on 3/09/2011 2:01PM
I moved away from the city for my kid to be in a better school district. Where she can receive an education and dosn't have to deal with children who's parent do not care about their own childs education and will let them act up in school. If I had moved away from Memphis to a school district where my child to go to a better school, then I would be PO'd that they let the riff-raff in as well.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Donald on 3/09/2011 7:32PM
Same here. Went to a parent-teacher conference and realized that I might as well be sending my child to school at the zoo. So now I'm in the 'burbs where people work hard every day and pay a bundle in taxes so the town's schools can afford the things children require for a decent education.
Why in the world would I want our schools polluted by the neglected bastard spawn of lazy welfare cheats? That's why I left Philly in the first place.
Report This
By: Bob on 3/12/2011 4:32PM
Wow... Those were two of the more unequivocally racist comments I have heard in my life, the only more explicit ones originating from a Memphian's drunken rant in favor of slavery.
Lest we forget that the origin of this debate does not come from the city school's desire to merge districts, but from the suburban schools desire to separate. The city schools would have lost two thirds of their funding if the dramatically wealthier suburbs would have broken off. For them, this was more of a fight for survival than a matter of bureaucratic maneuvering.
Dr. Watkins is absolutely correct when he postulates that this is a simple reiteration of Jim Crow style segregation.
Parents, you should be proud of wanting only the best for your children. You should be deeply shamed by the fact that you would be willing to legally and economically segregate them (thereby denying other children a fair education) to achieve it.
Report This
By: Jim Hall on 3/09/2011 5:49PM
To no ones' surprise, we see that segregation is alive and doing very well in Shelby County TN and Memphis as well! so what's new about that?
Isn't Memphis/Shelby County the home of confederate general Bedford C. Forrest, one of the principal founders of the KKK and known for his saying of being "... the firstest with the mostest!" and having a memorial statue in a large Memphis park?
And why did the predominantly Black COGIC denomination decide to move it's annual convention to St. Louis in 2010 afetr holding it for 100 years in Memphis, it's home base?
Come on, wake up people, it's the SOS, just a different day!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Eugene Rhodes on 3/10/2011 5:21PM
"Where is this NOT happening"? We seen in Ohio where a woman seen the need to gain a quality education for her child she had to use a 'wrong address'! For this a judge wanted to 'jail her' and / or fine her almost $30,000! Blame should be placed on the people that had the responsibilty to provide 'quilty' education to All! Past 'politicans' and elected officials have not been held 'accountable'!!!!! They have made there money, moved on and provided for 'their' own!!! Detroit Michigan is a present example!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: M. Douglas on 3/10/2011 6:14PM
I am a black woman that lives in Shelby County and completely against the merger. Watkins you need to get your facts straight. This is not about the children this is all political. The same board that surrenders is going to try to come to Shelby county board and tell them how to run things. They should not be allowed in the door. How will a merger help? Now come on. Look at the voter turnout. Those parents do not care.
Instead of talking about how ashamed the county should be you need to talk about how ashamed the city parents are for not voting. The don’t care but you want Shelby County to have all the answers. I am quite sure we will be securitized for every decision we make.
How is a merger going to help a school of teenagers from getting pregnant? I can go on and on. We do not need to merge. The suggestions MSC has for Shelby county use them for your schools. We are fine over here. Please, Please. Do not let any of them board members on the new team. They surrendered remember. That’s mean I can’t do it. Somebody made a statement that the county leaders do not have any suggestion. Are You kidding me this was forced upon us. He did not ask for this crap.
No one have answers. Good thing Nashville did get involved. The city wanted to force this upon the county immediately with no planning. What a joke. Those same board members want to be a part of our board. (Stay away you could not do the job with what you had) Let the county vote on that. We had no say in this whole deal. Is that fair.
Who forced a big system into a little one. With no planning. It like a parent of 5 dropping her kids off to a parent of 1 and say hey take them I do not want them. I give up!!!!
Let me hear you say something about those parents. They need some accountability for their own kids.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: motherlove on 3/10/2011 10:47PM
I WILL PRAY FOR YOU ALL AND MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON OUR CHILDREN BECAUSE YOU ADULTS ARE SCARY, BIASED, AND BIGOTED BOTH BLACK AND WHITE. AND FOR THE RECORD PARENTS IN THE CITY DO CARE, THEY DECIDED TO VOTE BECAUSE THEY FEEL THIS IS NOT ABOUT THE KIDS BUT THE EGOS OF POLITICIANS AND ARROGANCE OF THOSE LIVING IN THE COUNTY. THIS SITUATION IS MESSY, VINDICTIVE, AND OFFENSIVE. CONSOLIDATE OR NOT I SUGGEST TO THE CITIZENS OF MEMPHIS AND OTHER METRO AREAS TO TAKE THE EDUCATION OF THEIR KIDS INTO THEIR OWN HANDS BECAUSE NO-ONE REALLY CARES ABOUT THE EDUCATION OF INNER-CITY CHILDREN, AFTER ALL THE USA DOES NEED A PERMANENT UNDERCLASS. EDUCATE EVERYONE AND WHO BECOMES MEDIOCRE.
Report This
By: Airet on 3/11/2011 5:15AM
Are these people really arguing about educating children.....in America....land of the free....givers to the world? Wow. The Bible teaches us in Deut 15:11 "There will always be poor people in the land. Therefore I command you to be openhanded (helpful) toward your fellow Israelites who are poor and needy in your land." Proverbs 11:25 The generous will prosper; those who refresh (restore, help) others will themselves be refreshed.
These poor children need to be educated and if you can afford to do that then help. Stop the hate and fear; open your hearts to love.
We shall overcome someday.
Reply to this Comment | Report This